Where to next, love suggestions! Raja Ampat, PNG...

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I think Alor would meet your requirements BUT july-august are not optimal for nudibranch season.
On the other hand I take Alor as the best spot in Indonesia for rhinopias spotting, tied with Ambon and Padang Bai/Bali.
Alor also proposes GREAT blue water dives.

Not sure for Raja Ampat as a Macro spot in July. Triton bay would be closed too.
Cannot say for Milne bay, I will go there next march hoping to put it somewhere high on my macro scene scale :)
 
I've been able to get in to Tawali on less than 2 weeks notice before. That being said, July is not just North American summer school holidays, but also Australian winter school holidays - and PNG is only a very short flight north for most Aussies. Lots of people travel then. Late July would likely be easier, because most Aus schools would be back in session by then.

July in PNG might be a bit windy and have some rougher boat trips, but that has little effect on the diving in my experience. The macro/muck sites are more sheltered anyway, but some of the outer reef trips they do might be a bit rough. The boat they use for the outer reefs is pretty big and stable though.

What about August in PNG (So I can see the Mt. Hagen festival in addition to diving Tawali)?

- Bill
 
Just came back from Alor. Liked it really much and saw critters which I've never seen before. A bit less expensive than PNG.. You find pictures on my flickr-account: https://flic.kr/s/aHskFQ5Wfy . Will write a trip report soon.

I look forward to your trip report! how much blue water or current diving?

- Bill
 
What about August in PNG (So I can see the Mt. Hagen festival in addition to diving Tawali)?

- Bill

June-August in PNG is winter. It gets windy in winter. But like I said, Milne Bay is mostly protected in the bay, it's only the outer reef visits that will be rough. Australian winter school holidays generally run mid-June to mid-July, so if you can avoid that, you should be ok.

That being said, given your apparent dislike of Lembeh, I have to question why Milne Bay (Tawali) is on your list? It's nearly all macro/muck diving...Why not look at Tufi, or Kavieng, or somewhere further north? They're more reefy, big animal, wreck locations.

Mt Hagen is in the highlands, and you need to be very very aware that there are security problems in the highlands of PNG. Please do not attempt to go there on your own - you need a guide.
 
I look forward to your trip report! how much blue water or current diving?

- Bill
Depends on the operator you go with, some are either muck or blue water oriented, I would say 70%-30% Blue/Muck with the operator I go with (Alor Eco Divers).
The odds of diving ito the current also depend on whether you like it or not.: the operator will assess your diving and your likings to match with the selection of dive sites. Not more than 20% dive sites with signficant current
 
I don't want to confuse everyone but I can either take a vacation in my summer (June/July) or during my sons fall break at end of September/beginning of October. So I am hoping that opens up different diving areas and possibilities.

To answer a few questions posted... Alor has been on my list of interest. I think someone mentioned that summer might not be good time there for nudibranchs but how is it in October? Same question for Misool area?

For PNG: How is the safety and malaria there? I (42 and a single mother) will be going with my bodyguard father (LOL) and my 15 year old son. Do we need meds for malaria? How safe will we feel?

Misool and Triton Bay are of interest and I would love to hear more about both places. If anyone has anything else to share, I would love to hear it.
 
PNG:

Security depends entirely on where in PNG you go. Coastal areas are generally safe (avoid Lae entirely, and Port Moresby as much as possible though), the majority of security problems are in the highlands. Most of it is tribal violence or corruption, but tourists get caught up in it. If you're only going diving, it's not really an issue. But keep your transits in Port Moresby as short as is possible - schedule your flights to get in and out as quickly as possible.

I do consulting work in PNG, and am a 36 yo female. I will go diving there on my own, no issues. Outside of dive resorts and airports, I won't travel alone in PNG. Always have security with me.

Malaria exists. The dive resorts are almost all surrounded by jungle. I take doxycycline.
 
Last edited:
To answer a few questions posted... Alor has been on my list of interest. I think someone mentioned that summer might not be good time there for nudibranchs but how is it in October?
October is better in that respect, however I've been told optimal would be May.

Milne Bay is mostly protected in the bay, it's only the outer reef visits that will be rough. Australian winter school holidays generally run mid-June to mid-July, so if you can avoid that, you should be ok.
Can you enlighten me about PNG and Milne bay.? Since I read many good things on this board (and wanted to go to PNG since a long time), I bit the bullet and booked a week stay at Tawali.
Is it really a muck place like Lembeh or Ambon bay, I thought I would have my share of lively reefs (Deacon, etc.)?
Regarding Port Moresby any hint on where to stay overnight not overly expensive (I mean less than Airways hotel), what to do to spend the day in POM? Do you know interesting places for buying woodcarving, masks or ethnic items?
I can speak bislama pidgin from Vanuatu but I am not sure it's understood and an advantage too...
 
Looking for a different place that I haven't been diving in Indonesia or possibly going to PNG. I have been to Komodo, Talumben/Seraya, Padang Bai, Nusa Lembongan, Lembeh, and now just returned from Ambon. I am into macro/weird critters (especially nudibranchs, rhinopias, pygmy seahorse) but am kind of intrigued about seeing wobbegongs as well. Thinking either about Misool area in Raja Ampat or PNG. Does anyone have any good input about either? or suggestions? This group steered me towards Ambon and I was quite happy there but there weren't a whole lot of nudis to see in my opinion. Would definitely consider going back there again though in the future. Thanks in advance!
Check this out LAST MINUTE DEAL Raja Ampat 20% Off Maybe it is time to go for Raja :wink:
 
October is better in that respect, however I've been told optimal would be May.


Can you enlighten me about PNG and Milne bay.? Since I read many good things on this board (and wanted to go to PNG since a long time), I bit the bullet and booked a week stay at Tawali.
Is it really a muck place like Lembeh or Ambon bay, I thought I would have my share of lively reefs (Deacon, etc.)?
Regarding Port Moresby any hint on where to stay overnight not overly expensive (I mean less than Airways hotel), what to do to spend the day in POM? Do you know interesting places for buying woodcarving, masks or ethnic items?
I can speak bislama pidgin from Vanuatu but I am not sure it's understood and an advantage too...

Port Moresby: I know it is expensive, but I stay at the Airways Hotel for a reason. It is safe. Every expat I know who works in PNG stays there. I cannot recommend anywhere else for security reasons, sorry. I also cannot provide advice on spending the day in POM. It isn't safe. Violent crime there is common. When I attend meetings in town, I have a bulletproof vehicle and an armed escort. Make of that what you will. There is a reason people avoid layovers in POM, which is why I recommend scheduling flights to avoid layovers. I know it's hard for people to wrap their heads around...But POM and Lae have serious problems :(

Milne Bay: The dive sites near Tawali are coastal fringing reefs, but they are basically macro dives. Might see a ray or a reef shark if you're lucky. A bit further up the bay there are more traditional muck dives, much like you would find in Lembeh or Ambon. About 2 hours up the bay there are a couple of pinnacles, and there are some bigger fish around. Out of the bay, in the other direction, about an hour away, are some smaller islands and more traditional reef drift dives (similar to Bunaken in my opinion).

That being said, in my experience at Tawali, the dive boats tend to mainly stick to the macro/muck sites in the bay. You can convince them to do the pinnacle and reef dives if enough guests are interested, but it's kind of like Ambon in that people go there for macro, not reefs. You may have a hard time convincing the other guests to skip the macro.

The resort at Tawali sells carvings. I have a few at home (marine life carvings, tribal masks, etc.). Also, they get local carvers pulling up to the resort wharf to sell things. The international departures lounge at POM on the way out also sells traditional souvenirs.

Not sure about your pidgin dialect, but most people you are likely to encounter speak reasonable English. Half the tv in PNG comes from Australia :)
 

Back
Top Bottom