Dive Accident on Belize Aggressor

Discussion in 'Accidents and Incidents' started by Jan Neufeld Adair, Mar 26, 2012.

  1. Jan Neufeld Adair

    Jan Neufeld Adair Garibaldi

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: United States
    4
    18
    0
    My Belize scuba diving vacation aboard the Belize Aggressor. . .great for the first 3 days. But, then I had a scuba diving accident on Jan 3 that resulted in a near drowning and heart attack. Third world hospital in Belize was not a great place, so doctor there had me medically evacuated back home to Leesburg Regional's ICU. Came home Monday, Jan. 9 night. Heart cath showed I had a healthy heart and the only reason I had a heart attack was from lack of oxegyn due to sea water aspiration. We had gotten caught in a very strong current. The conditions on that last dive were bad and seemed to turn worse during our dive. We made the decision to turn back early. We were doing our stop under the boat. We even saw the ladders when we were in 30 ft. We came up to 20 feet and then hung out at 20 foot for several more minutes. Then the boat disappeared from sight. We tried to wait there, thinking it would swing back. It did not. My husband surfaced to get a direction and we headed in that direction. We had to swim into the current to get back to the boat. I was swimming into the current with ankle weights on (supid). I forgot they were there. I should have dumped them, but did not. I guess swimming with the ankle weights on added to my exhaustion. When we realized there was no way to get back to the boat, we surfaced and signaled for help. We both inflated our BCs and waited for the rescue raft. When the dive instructor got to us, I handed up to him my camera and the weight pockets from the BCD. I was not able to get up in the raft with the tank and other gear on, so the dive instructor removed my BC, tank and regulator. When he removed my BCD and tank, I sank (ankle weights) as a wave raised the raft over my head. I was under the raft gasping for air. I guess that’s when I aspirated so much sea water. As I was trying to kick to get a hold of the grasp handle on the side of the raft, it seemed it was just inches out of reach as each wave raised the raft out of my reach. After multiple trys to grab on, it seemed impossible. At that moment, I gave up. I thought there was no way possible to get into the raft. The dive instructor did not give up on me. He kept saying “you will get up here” and “and we are going to do this”. I am so thankful for his calm, but forceful confidence that encouraged me to give it all I could to get into that raft. I know he was bailing water and trying to maneuver the raft as he helped my husband up into the raft. He kept a level head and made a rescue. We had a 4 hour boat ride back in to Belize city. At first we thought I had just aspirated sea water, but by morning it was apparent that I also had a heart attack. This could have been so much worse, but God has much more for me in this life.

    I know leaving ankle weights on was my fault,but I believe the crew of the Belize Aggressor had some responsibility in all this too. They have not stepped up in any way to accept their responsibility. The weather was bad the whole trip. We skipped the first dive in the morning, made the second dive and skipped the 3rd dive. The guys that made the 3rd dive said they thought conditions were too rough for any more diving. An hour later, the Captain said let's dive. We trusted the Captain to know the conditions as he is on these waters frequently. I know ultimately it is my responsibility to decide if a dive is safe for me, but the captain said it was ok. Next, the current was so strong there was a long dely in getting the raft out to us. They had to use 3 men to pull the raft up to the boat. I believe they had an electric winch, but didn't use it. Next, they only sent one guy in the raft to rescue us. I am 6 foot 1 inch - they should have known, he would need help getting me up into the raft. Further, with 2 guys in the rescue raft, they could have pulled me in with all my gear on. I would not have aspirated sea water and would not have had a heart attack. Additionally, I had been using one of their regulators. I am not sure that it was delivering enough oxygen. I have been in current before and never got this short of breath.

    I am wondering if any one else sees that the dive operator had some share of responsibility in this accident. I like to hear what you think.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Mar 26, 2012
  2. awap

    awap Giant Squid

    # of Dives:
    Location: Central TX
    14,256
    3,342
    113
    In what way do you see the operator having any responsibility for your failure to remove your ankle weights?
     
    deepair, OttoDog, oly5050user and 8 others like this.
  3. lulubelle

    lulubelle Single Diver

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location:
    863
    95
    0
    Glad you got the care you needed and that you are recovering. Thanks for sharing your experience, these reports can only serve to help someone else stay safe.

    It sounds to me that all appropriate rescue procedures were followed by the crew of the boat. Removing gear in order to keep a victim afloat or to lift them into a boat is what a rescue diver is trained to do. I'm sure given that you were alert and had your feet in the water, the rescuer did not know that you had ankle weights on or they would have likely instructed you to remove them.

    Ditching gear and weights to remain buoyant at the surface is your responsibility unless you are unable to and your dive buddy jumps in to help. And it is always your responsibility to determine if conditions on any given dive are safe for you.

    Focus on your recovery and I'm glad you are OK.
     
    beaverdivers and AfterDark like this.
  4. tadawson

    tadawson Barracuda

    # of Dives: 50 - 99
    Location: Lewisville, Texas
    200
    38
    0
    A rescue diver is also trained to visibly review the victims gear to make sure that they deal with it correctly. This appears to have not happened here, or the ankle weights would have been seen and dealt with.

    Having said that, despite rescue training, I don't know if I would think to look for ankle weights either . . . . .

    And I do question the wisdom of any weight configuration that when the ditchable part is gone, leaves you negatively buoyant . . .

    - Tim
     
  5. MMM

    MMM Administrator Staff Member

    # of Dives: 500 - 999
    Location: Sask. Canada/Cozumel, MX
    7,532
    1,463
    113
    It sounds like a scarey dive but I don't know I would attribute your experience to the dive op.

    Swimming against current is difficult at the best of times. I'm lazy and I would have just sent up a safety sausage, surfaced, and waited for them to pick me up. It would have been less stressful and you would have had more strength to get onto the raft. It is a lot of task loading, I am sure if you aren't experienced at getting onto a raft, but the crew can't know that you are good at doing that or not. Was your husband/buddy back on the raft and helping to pull you in?

    How is your physical fitness? When I was being certified in Aruba many years ago, I had some difficulty hauling myself into the inflatable dinghy they were using to take me to some training sites. I decided I needed to go to a gym and build up my upper body strength to perform those sorts of maneuvers. Well, lower body strength also so I could climb up a ladder with all my gear on but that is another issue.
     
    Tigger5020 and Hatul like this.
  6. Mike

    Mike Great White

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: Denver, Colorado
    3,952
    2,710
    0
    You had me really feeling sorry, right up to the point you ditched all accountability and started looking for a scape goat. Please stop and accept personal accountability and responsibility for your accident. We have to play the cards we are dealt with in life and you dealt yours to yourself, your hands placed the ankle weights upon your own ankles, your own hands failed to remove them prior to removing your BC, more importantly, you failed to ditch them prior to recognizing the dangers of exhausting yourself swimming against the current.

    I'm glad you survived your accident, it sounds like it could have been much worse, it sounds like you owe the crew of the aggressor for saving your life, please don't destroy your dignity looking to place your own blame on others now, I hope in time you can not seek out others to blame for this. Focus on the future. How old are you by the way if you don't mind sharing?
     
    Rhodesaz, OttoDog, txpig and 12 others like this.
  7. TC

    TC Miscreant Moderator Staff Member ScubaBoard Supporter

    5,865
    365
    83
    Ankle weights are normally only a few pounds per pair- not something that should impede helping someone into a raft.

    I wouldn't think taking the time to check for and/or remove them would be appropriate in a rescue situation.
     
  8. wedivebc

    wedivebc CCR Instructor ScubaBoard Supporter

    # of Dives:
    Location: Vancouver Island
    4,919
    661
    113
    Sounds like you had a bad day, I'm glad you came out of it OK but I would hardly call that a dive accident, maybe a dive boo boo.
    I am really distressed that you would try and attribute any of the blame of your failure to remove ankle weights on the dive operator.
    If you want to blame anyone you should sue the dive instructor who told you that you needed ankle weights in the first place.
    Seriously though this society has become completely incapable of taking responsibility for our own screw ups.
    If that was in your mind a dive accident maybe you should take up golf.
     
  9. N2DeepInAz

    N2DeepInAz Scuba Instructor

    # of Dives: 500 - 999
    Location: Phoenix, Arizona
    328
    26
    0
    I'm glad to see you're doing well after this incident however, I'm curious what responsibility they had to you that they failed to uphold. :dontknow:


    Sending one person out in a skiff is pretty standard from what I've seen in most parts of the world. Removing your gear is typically the only way you're going to be able to hoist yourself into the skiff. Failing to remove all of your weights before removing your BCD cannot be seen as anyone's fault but your own. Perhaps you weren't familiar with the type of diving you were doing? The seas can change in a heartbeat and they certainly aren't the Captains fault as he can't control the weather any better than you could. The Captain can only allow or deny access to the water for diving. He cannot make the decision to dive for you, that is up to you. If the conditions were outside of your comfort levels, then you should heavily consider skipping the dive. To dive or not to dive, the decision & responsibility is yours solely.

    As for the regulator not delivering enough air...well, my only question is, was it working throughout the dive? If so, chances are you were overexerted and over breathing the regulator which at that particular moment can feel like the reg isn't delivering enough airflow. We are taught when we are overexerted that we should stop what we are doing and rest for a moment to catch our breath. I understand you were in current which can then be a difficult thing to do. At that point, I would have signaled my buddy that the dive was over and we were going to surface. Anyone can call a dive at anytime for any reason. It's all about being safe and making smart decisions in the water. Overexertion has been known to cause heart attacks.

    So it seems to me that the the staff of the Aggressor did everything correctly. Not being there personally makes it harder for us to pass judgment but it seems in line with the norm. You mentioned you handed them your weights from your BCD, well that should've triggered something in your memory to remove your ankle weights too. In the future, never give up your BCD unless you have a firm hold on something buoyant or you're positively buoyant for sure.

    Rest up, get your doctor to clear you to get back in the water and go do some more diving.
     
    Jim Lapenta likes this.
  10. Bratface

    Bratface Humbolt Squid

    # of Dives: 1,000 - 2,499
    Location: St Thomas, VI
    1,592
    182
    63
    I am glad you are here to tell your story, but there is no liability on the dive operation or dive master. They did all they could to keep you from drowning at the surface, and getting you medical care. For that you should be thankful. There is a huge personal responsibility in diving. Any diver can call the dive at any time for any reason, but you chose to swim back to the boat against the current wearing ankle weights which you admit you should have ditched.

    It seems that you were flown out as quickly as arrangements could be made to a state side hospital, and you survived the care given to you in a "third world" hospital. No one thinks they will find themselves in a foreign hospital, so we never stop to think about that equipment they have and the training of the staff. Believe me, they are doing the best they can with what they've got, and it seems they did pretty good for you.

    There is no need to analyze your accident any further. Thank you for sharing your event. Concentrate on your healing and get back to the water when you are ready.
     
  11. SC_Hoaty

    SC_Hoaty Orca

    # of Dives: 25 - 49
    Location: SC
    5,595
    4,012
    0
    Welcome to ScubaBoard - quite the first post! Glad you are around to tell your story.

    One of the items that may be missed in the whole adventure is the "trust me" aspect. Conditons were poor, but you deferred to the captain. I suspect many, many divers do the same each day on vacation. Perhaps, as part of that trust, you had hoped they would do more to prevent the problems you encountered. I hope others learn from your post about the pitfalls in trusting others with your own life and safety.

    Best wishes for a full, complete, and quick recovery.
     
    openmindOW, JG109 and RubberDucky like this.
  12. Wookie

    Wookie ScubaBoard Business Sponsor ScubaBoard Business Sponsor

    7,081
    7,875
    113
    Sorry, Jan, but when the Captain opens the dive deck, that means you have permission to go diving, not that you must, should, need, or have to go diving. The Captain is not responsible for your skills, personal health, gear configuration, or lack thereof. The Captain's job is to get you safely to the dive site, set up the boat in a proper manner in accordance with their own internal procedures (which you may have reviewed, but probably didn't before the dive), and provide a trained staff to help you when you get in over your head, as it were. It is not the Captain's job to evaluate your diving skills, limit your diving to confined water like conditions, or evaluate your medical fitness for diving.

    Conditions change out in the big ocean. Just because conditions were suitable for diving when he opened the dive deck for diving doesn't mean that conditions will remain static for the hour or so of your dive. One thing we can say about the weather, if you don't like it, just wait a minute.

    If there is one thing I have learned about divers in my 20 or so years of working on liveaboards, people lose their minds when you place a camera in their hands. Responsible photographers know and take responsibility for this and do the things that they need to do to keep themselves alive when they forget to check their air, or get in a current, or fail to remove their ankle weights when the crap is hitting the fan.

    When we sign up to go on a liveaboard, we put our big girl panties on and understand that we're doing diving that is more remote from help and more adventurous than walking off the rocks in Bonaire. The ocean has currents and waves and toothy fish and things that sting and lots and lots of ways to get hurt. That's why we go on liveaboards. You'd probably be a lot safer in the LDS pool, but it would be boring as hell.

    I think you should write a very nice thank you note to Aggressor Fleet, to the Captain, and to the crew of the Belize Aggressor who undoubtedly saved your life at the cost of hundreds of dollars of fuel to get you to the hospital in Belize City. I also think you should apologize to your fellow divers and passengers on the Aggressor for that week for missing any dives (if they did) while they had to run you in. Last, I'd ask one of the mods to delete this entire thread because it does a gross disservice to the folks at Aggressor Fleet who work very hard to provide an adventure for divers and a chance for folks to see a part of the world that only fishermen and wealthy yachties would know if it weren't for their efforts. But hey, that's just me.
     
    MarianneR, OttoDog, DanBMW and 36 others like this.
  13. AfterDark

    AfterDark Orca

    # of Dives:
    Location: Rhode Island,USA
    7,082
    2,623
    113
    Glad you're ok. No I don't see any fault with the op. I've called dives for me because I didn't agree with the Capt, and DM that the sea was diveable at the time. Unless you are in very good shape swimming against currents is not something one should be doing. Entering boats in rough seas in also something for the young and fit. By the way are you a reporter? "Additionally, I had been using one of their regulators. I am not sure that it was delivering enough oxygen".
     
  14. Bratface

    Bratface Humbolt Squid

    # of Dives: 1,000 - 2,499
    Location: St Thomas, VI
    1,592
    182
    63
    I hope you are still with us, Jan, reading everything and taking it all in.

    Having read all the posts again, I have to agree with a nice letter of thanks, maybe with a nice tip for the Captain and DM and a fat check for the third world hospital who rendered your care. I am sure they could use it.
     
  15. openmindOW

    openmindOW Scuba Instructor

    1,465
    127
    0
    I am very glad that you are okay, Jan.

    Thank you for posting on ScubaBoard.

    My preliminary guess is that the operator bears no legal responsibility here.

    Sometimes things go wrong and no one is to blame.

    Keep diving.
     
  16. Mike

    Mike Great White

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: Denver, Colorado
    3,952
    2,710
    0
    There is a great deal of good information here that would be lost. A good deal of information that others would miss out on. The message of accountability and being responsible for your own actions is loud and clear in the responses. This world needs as much of that as it can get.
     
  17. wedivebc

    wedivebc CCR Instructor ScubaBoard Supporter

    # of Dives:
    Location: Vancouver Island
    4,919
    661
    113
    I disagree I think it speaks well for the Aggressor Fleet but maybe not so well for the OP.
    Now I might agree it be moved to the whine and cheese forum;)
     
    AfterDark likes this.
  18. Ayisha

    Ayisha Surface Interval Member

    # of Dives: 200 - 499
    Location: Toronto, Canada
    2,198
    606
    113
    Remember that the OP had a heart attack due to aspiration while diving. That would certainly count as an accident while diving.

    The rest of your post (and others) about accountability for oneself and responsibility for one's actions and choices I agree with.
     
  19. mathauck0814

    mathauck0814 Humbolt Squid

    # of Dives:
    Location: Killington, VT & San Diego, CA
    2,029
    758
    0
    I have yet to meet the diver who actually needs ankle weights. Much less when diving tropically and wet.
     
  20. MMM

    MMM Administrator Staff Member

    # of Dives: 500 - 999
    Location: Sask. Canada/Cozumel, MX
    7,532
    1,463
    113
    I agree. I see more divers moving vertically, not horizontally.
     

Share This Page