First regulators for a new diver--MK25?

Discussion in 'Regulators' started by Cheeky, Jun 10, 2012.

  1. Cheeky

    Cheeky Nassau Grouper

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: Canada
    97
    32
    0
    Im new to diving but am hooked and plan on doing much more. I have decided to start purchasing some equipment and am checking out regulators. I am rather impressed with ScubaPro MK25/G250V combo. I'm planning on diving here in Saskatchewan during the summer months and I also spend 4-5 weeks in the Caribbean each winter. I will be recreational and no deeper than 100 ft.

    Can anyone share their thoughts on this setup or recommend something to suit my needs-future plans.

    Thanks!!
     
  2. MG11

    MG11 Deep South DIR

    # of Dives: 0 - 24
    Location: GA
    150
    27
    0
  3. Cheeky

    Cheeky Nassau Grouper

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: Canada
    97
    32
    0
  4. Quero

    Quero Will be missed

    # of Dives: I just don't log dives
    Location: Phuket, Thailand
    9,501
    2,253
    0

    ** MOD POST: **

    Moved to Regulators forum.
     
  5. Kunundrum

    Kunundrum Divemaster

    # of Dives: I just don't log dives
    Location: Ajax Ont. Canada
    290
    24
    0
    the MK25 is a great Regulator, I like the S600 2nd stage with the metal air barrel or A700 Vs. the G250V, though there is nothing wrong with the 250, I just find it a little large.

    the C200 would make a nice octo Nice and small and breathe pretty good too.
     
  6. Doomnova

    Doomnova Nassau Grouper

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: Playing go fish with the fishies :D
    197
    46
    0
    I use an s600 MK25 combo and honestly love it. I have to hide it from my friends for fear of them running off with it. :D
     
  7. halocline

    halocline Orca

    7,122
    1,541
    113
    Not good enough, as a new diver planning on easy warm water dives you need an atomic titanium!;)

    Seriously the MK25/G250V is a top shelf reg, way more than you'll ever actually need, if you don't mind spending the money go for it. I'm sure your LDS will be appreciative!
     
  8. Cheeky

    Cheeky Nassau Grouper

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: Canada
    97
    32
    0
    I'll be doing cold water diving in northern canada as well so that's why I was thinking about the high end set up. Is there much difference between the MK25 and 17?
     
  9. elan

    elan DIR Practitioner

    # of Dives: 200 - 499
    Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
    3,316
    376
    0
    There is a huge difference between the MK25 and MK17, MK17 being more suitable for cold water and although they are a bit cheaper they are not less high-end regs.

    MK17 balanced sealed diaphragm with a dry chamber, no internal parts are exposed to the environment.
    MK25 balanced piston with wet ambient chamber, the water stays in the chamber at all times and if frozen will cause the regulator to freeflow, especially if the reg is exposed to the outside freezing temps.

    As you are a new diver and live in Canada and this is your first! and probably the only for sometime regulator in your shoes I would definitely go with MK17 as it gives you more margin for an operator error in the cold water.

    MK25 needs to be treated carefully in water with a temp below 40F. You need to have a good cold water techniques to dive it in cold water especially when the temperature is freezing outside. If improperly handled pre dive in those conditions the chances that MK25 will freeze are way greater.

    Myself I have started diving MK25/G250V this season in temps around 40f and so far they were behaving great. When I started my diving I bought a diaphragm reg (Zeagle FH6, similar to MK17) and as my techniques were far from being any good I managed to get even a dry diaphragm regs frozen :)

    I bought my MK25s because I love how they route on doubles. I still use my diaphragm regs (Zeagle FH 6) for the very cold season.

    MK17/G250V is an outstanding regulator and you will unlikely grow up from that combo and will unlikely regret purchasing the one. My buddy has been diving his MK17/G250V from day one and never was disappointed, he now has 4 sets.
     
  10. CaveMD

    CaveMD NAUI Instructor

    # of Dives: I'm a Fish!
    Location: Durham, North Carolina, United States
    478
    51
    0
    I use hog d1colds. They are balanced sealed diaphragms and I've used them down to 39 degree at 160' and they worked just fine. I use the same on all my stage bottles and decompression bottles.

    Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
     
  11. SnorkelLA

    SnorkelLA Surface Interval Member

    # of Dives: 200 - 499
    Location: The Water
    438
    44
    0
    I second the HOG D1s. And you appear to be from Canada (I can't see if you set your location from Tapatalk) the DIN valves that these regs require will probably be much more available than in the US


    Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
     
  12. halocline

    halocline Orca

    7,122
    1,541
    113
    What do you mean by cold water? Sub 40F? Do you have a drysuit? If not, chances are pretty slim that you'll ever be in water cold enough to freeze the MK25, especially when paired with the G250. But, the MK17 is also a very fine regulator and there would be zero disadvantage going with the MK17 instead. Either will work great, unless you do have a drysuit and therefore access to extremely cold water, in which case the MK17 is a better choice. The G250V is a great 2nd stage for either of those first stages. The MK17 does have the advantage of being less expensive.
     
  13. Cheeky

    Cheeky Nassau Grouper

    # of Dives: 100 - 199
    Location: Canada
    97
    32
    0
    No dry suit yet but it's something I want to work towards. With that in mind I thought the MK would serve as my main reg for a broader spectrum of diving.

    ---------- Post added ----------

    No dry suit yet but it's something I want to work towards. With that in mind I thought the MK would serve as my main reg for a broader spectrum of diving.

    ---------- Post added ----------

    So sorry for the typos and double post! Meant to say MK17
     

Share This Page