For meat, my favorite is El Gaucho located downtown. Their signature dish is the Churrasco or Gaucho steak. 16oz of pure Argentine beef. It practically melts in your mouth. Reservations are suggested:
El Gaucho Restaurant Aruba - HOME
For Italian our favorite is Sole Mare, near the High Rises. They have two sister restaurants, Gianni's across from the Radisson and Azzurro at the Playa Linda. I have read reports that the quality at Azzurro has diminished lately.
Here's a long but maybe not complete list of restaurants in the High Rise area alone. Where possible I've included directions and the type of cusine. Most restautants on the island are casual and you can wear shorts into:
Aruba Marriott Resort & Stellaris Casino
Ketsu Sushi Bar - Japanese
La Vista - International
Ruth Cris Steakhouse
Simply Fish - Seafood
Wave's Beach Bar & Grill - American
Marriott Aruba Ocean Club
Champions Sports Bar
Pavilion
Marriott Aruba Surf Club
Captain's Galley
Holiday Inn Sunspree Aruba Beach Resort & Casino
Miramar Restaurant
SeeBreeze Grille
Boardwalk Caf
Corals Restaurant
Caff Da Vinci
Playa Linda Beach Resort
Aromi d'Italia
Sushi Ya - Japanese/Sushi
Azzurro - Italian
Haagen Dazs
Le Petite Caf
Dushi Bagel
Charlie's Grill
Subway
Dunkin Donuts/ Baskin & Robbins
Hyatt Regency Beach Resort
Ruinas del Mar - Continental
Caf Japengo - pan Asian
Caf Piccolo - Italian
Palms
Foot Prints Beach Grill
Occidental Grand Resort (former Allegro)
The Palm - International Buffet
L 'Olio - Italian
El Olvido - Mexican
Zen - Asian
The Pizzeria
The Beach Club
Radisson Aruba Resort & Casino
Sunset Grille
Laguna Fish Market
Gilligan's Beach Bar and Grill
Hotel Riu Aruba Grand (former Aruba Grand)
The Westin Aruba Resort
Bon Bini Caf
Rick's Caf
Blossoms
Pago Pago
Caffe Baci
Tambu Bar
Azull
The Lobby Bar
Divi Aruba Phoenix Beach Resort
Sunset Bistro
French Market and Deli
Brickell Bay
Tomato Charlie's
Hooters
Benihana
The Mill Resort & Suites
The Garden Caf Restaurant
Restaurants close by, within walking distance:
Moomba Beach Bar & Restaurant
Between Marriott & Holiday Inn Website
Pelican's Nest
On pier between Holiday Inn & Playa Linda
Tony Roma's
Across road from Holiday Inn Website
Smokey Joe's
Across road from Playa Linda
Sbarros
Across road from Playa Linda
Texas de Brazil
Across road from Playa Linda Website
Amici's
Across road from Playa Linda
Tango
Across road from Occidental / Next to Brickell Bay
Salt & Pepper
Across road from Occidental / Next to Brickell Bay
Sopranos
Across road from Occidental / Next to Brickell Bay
Amazonia Churrascaria
Near Brickell Bay Website
Aqua Grill
Near Brickell Bay
Hostaria da Vittorio
Behind Brickell Bay
Hadicurari -
Between Holiday Inn and Marriott Website
Gianni's
Across road from Radisson
Benihana's
at Brickell Bay
Hooter's
at Brickell Bay
Tomato Charlie's
at Brickell Bay
Daniel's Steak and Chops
Across road from Radisson
Along or just off the road from the High Rises towards Noord. Most can be walked to:
Mc Donald's
Wendy's
Dominos
Sole Mare
Bella Luna
Long Walks off the main road to Noord. Safe, but best with a group.
The Old Cunucu House - Aruban
Website
Buccaneer - Seafood - Food is so-so, but if yo uhave kids they'll love the giant aquarium
Gaparito's - Aruban
Website
Papiamento - Aruban
Website
Linda's Pancakes & Pizza