Welcome to ScubaBoard, an online scuba diving forum community where you can join over 185,000 divers from around the world discussing all things related to Scuba Diving. To gain full access to ScubaBoard (and make this large box go away) you must register for a free account. As a registered member you will be able to:
Participate in over 500 dive topic forums and browse from over 5,500,000 posts.
Communicate privately with other divers from around the world.
Post your own photos or view from well over 100,000 user submitted images.
Gain access to our free classifieds marketplace to buy, sell and trade gear, travel and services.
Use the calendar to organize your events and enroll in other members' events.
All this and much more is available to you absolutely free when you register for an account, so sign up today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact the ScubaBoard Support Team.
For almost a decade I have been teaching how to handle a free flowing regulator using the "corner out of the mouth and sip" technique. Yesterday, sitting in the pool with my latest class whilst timing the 30 seconds, I wondered if this is really the best way.
Why not simply tell them to hold the reg in their mouths and allow the excess airflow to exit through the exhaust valves? It works, I know, because I tried it.
Surely far safer than expecting someone to ascend safely with a regulator half way in, using a technique practiced once in a pool?
That is what I do now. I was in the pool practicing sipping a freeflowing reg and realized I was so rustY I couldn't do it and would have drown if I had to rely on that skill. I then proceeded to try what you did and it worked better and there is no chance of forgetting how to breath out of a reg. You can turn your head to have the exhaust flow up and away from your mask to keep bubbles out of it and keep you mask from getting knocked off.
I've done it both ways, but find it is more comfortable to use the half in method. I find the positive pressure created by the all in method creates too much effort on exhalation. YMMV
I always assumed there was no leeway in how to teach it (PADI), because the skill sequence was specifically described. I've long believed that keeping the regulator fully in the mouth was the most 'fool-proof' method. In such circumstances, the diver is likely to be quite stressed - so the simplest option has a lot of attraction. Also, during such an ascent, there's likely to be a lot going on, plus bubbles everywhere, it'd be a lot easier to lose the reg from the mouth when it's held half-in.
I never heard that there was any practical reason that 'needed' the reg to be vented at the mouthpiece... but I didn't assume that there might not be a good reason for this, just because I hadn't heard of it. To balance off a rejection of simplicity and regulator retention, I'd hope that any such reason was based on a serious health and safety
The free flow sippy cup technique adds another level of familiarity with basic scuba gear, thus instills confidence in equipment ...
I was following my buddy a little too closely last weekend, and had my reg kicked halfway from my mouth by his wayward finning ... without learning to 'drink the bubbles' I likely wouldn't have handled the incident as comfortably ...
Last edited by currier; December 3rd, 2011 at 03:49 AM.
Just checked the exact requirements in the PADI instructor manual.
"Breathe effectively from a free-flowing regulator for not less than thirty seconds"
and the description includes the sentence
"Stress that students should not seal their mouths around the mouthpiece"
So no sipping required.
My next students will get a go at this method.
Interesting how we can sometimes get stuck into a routine passed on down the line.
As an aside, sometimes I wonder if it is a good idea that once qualified an instructor need never go and have his/her teaching skills and method assessed again.
Has Zombie left eye ala Marilyn Manson, but for real (Corneal Hydrops).
Join Date
Jul 2005
Location
South Santa Monica Bay/Los Angeles California, USA, Planet Earth, a blue world 71% water & third planet from a G2 yellow dwarf star, in the Milky Way Galaxy two thirds of the way out from the center on the inner edge of the Orion–Cygnus arm.
Just turn off your tank valve, and your uncontrollable free-flow is solved. All that noise & bubbles does is just add to the stress level --as well as waste precious breathing gas-- so just shut it down.
Breath your buddy's octo . . .or worst case being by yourself on single tank --breath your own octo or back-up reg and do a CESA. When you have to take in breaths during the ascent, feather/modulate your tank valve as needed and then shut it down (if your other reg is still free-flowing). Pause at 6m and perform a safety stop if you can with a slow ascent to the surface, remaining gas permitting . . .all the while feathering/modulating your tank valve again as needed for breaths.
A great drill for you and your buddy to practice. . .
"Luck is the residue of design."
Branch Rickey. "A Life is not important . . .except in the impact it has on other Lives."
Jackie Robinson. "Chance favors the prepared mind" --Louis Pasteur
Just turn off your tank valve, and your uncontrollable free-flow is solved....Breath your buddy's octo . .
This can be a solution for cold-related free-flows. Shut-down, ascend on buddy's AAS. After a few minutes try re-opening the valve. The freeze sometimes dissipates and the reg will function to continue the ascent.
Originally Posted by Kevrumbo
..being by yourself on single tank --breath your own octo or back-up reg and do a CESA.
Personally, I wouldn't shut down... just hold the free-flowing reg at arms length (reduced stress from bubbles) and breath from your own octo. The danger is that this reg may also free-flow (likely, if it is the 1st stage that's frozen). In which case, then shut down and CESA.
To be honest.. for the 'average' diver.. the free-flowing reg is gonna provide sufficient gas for a nice controlled CESA. Rather than shut-down, just breath the freeflow on the way up. If the bubbles are causing a safety issue through stress (feasible) just remove the reg from the mouth between breaths and hold it at arms length (sort of a solo buddy-breathing exercise).
11Likes
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Reply With Quote
Originally Posted by Kevrumbo
