difference between scorpionfish and stonefish

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

tomcat

Guest
Messages
148
Reaction score
0
Location
Singapore
How does one tell the difference between scorpion and stonefish? i have examined photos of both, looked at mouth shapes, fin structures, body profile...

By the way, do these things ever dart out at you to sting when threatened? Would be good to hear from someone who has been stung and lived to tell! :eek:
 
No they wont dart at you.

As for telling the difference between them-

if you catch a glimpse of a fish that looks exactly like a stone, it's probobly a scorpionfish. Beeing able to see a stonefish without anyone that knows the place showing you is VERY HARD and more close to impossible.

As for apearance: what you saw where probobly picture of stone and scorpin fish in profile. That's the only angle they can seem alike in. Stonefish is usualy a lot bigger that scorpionfish. if you look at a stonefish from above, it is kind of round (like a stone!) while a scorpionfish still have the shape of a fish- relatively long to it's width (though not as long as a swiming fish!). The eyes of a scorpionfish are a bit further of his body, standing on something like "stalks" made of bone (and the color of stone) while the eyes of a stonefish are IN his skull, very small and hard to notice. A scorpinfish's mouth is also pulled forward while a stonefish's mouth isn't. the stonefish's back fin (with poison) is much bigger, and the spines way thiker. There are several more differences, that was just off-hand. As a rule of thumb- is you see a stnelike creature and you'r not sure if it's a stonefish or a scrpion fish, that it's a scorpionfish. When you get to see a stonefish you will have no doubts about what it is once you discovered it isn't a stone.

As for another important difference- the stonefish's venom is much more danegerouse than that of the scorpionfish. It can (and did) kill. However, the stonefish is prety shy and unagressive, so if you don't provoke it, it will probobly tolerate your being very close to it (although a safety distance is highly advisable). If you do provoke it (VERY UNADVISABLE and dont even ask how I know it!!!) he will simply swim slowly away to a new spot. The scorpion is more nervouse, and if someone get's too close to it, it will run away (surprisingly, prety fast!).

Well, that's about it about scorpion and stone fish from me fore now!!!
 
we had a resident stonefish who lived right about where our boat moored on the beach. took a bit getting used to... they do not attack or dart at you. in fact one time myself and 3 other DMTs went out into the bay to practise our 20 skills and Lucy bent over in the water to put her fin on and rested her hand on this "rock" and it moved! after the initial shock and disbelief it was a right laff! hearing her scream and shout in a brazilian accent that "dis f***ing rock, she is movin'!" had us in stitches. needless to say we grabbed our camera and had a few portraits taken. the stonefish actually is much uglier than the scorpion fish and far more agile. the stonefish looks like it hops along the bottom.

James

ps. oh yes, lucy was fine.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom