Something to think about.

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

DivetheRock

Contributor
Messages
157
Reaction score
0
Location
Clarenville, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada
# of dives
0 - 24
Recently, I engaged in a conversation with my instructor regarding sealing, and diving in an area in which there are sealers (knowingly or unknowingly). BTW, this is not a pro/anti-sealing thread.
For those who, by some rare chance, do not know, Newfoundland and Labrador is a province in which there is a lot of sealing, and this covers many areas, not just that of the Gulf of St. Lawrence. I happen to live in a region where sealing and diving are done in the same area.
My question to all is have you ever thought much, or at all, about what a diver surfacing looks like compared to a seal surfacing? Remember, sealing often requires that the shooter be quick and have excellent marksmanship. Having said this, being quick and noticing a diver's snorkel or mask (regardless of colour) may be mutually exclusive.
I've never personally heard of any stories in which a diver was mistaken for a seal and shot. However, as the expression goes, "there's a first time for everything".
Of all the fears to have regarding diving, I think I've developed a fear of being mistakenly shot while diving...or surfacing, to be more precise. :thinkingo
 
Sounds like it's time to get an orange SMB and blow it on your safety stop. After three minutes, if they still shoot you, then they have a problem.

See? I thought about it.
 
Scary stuff, havent heard of it but wouldnt want to find out the wrong way. Guess a diver down flag would be coming in handy.
 
See, this is the problem. There are usually buoys everywhere in the water. Some for fishing nets, some for markers, etc. Another buoy or something floating in the water probably won't mean a whole lot, even if it is a "loud" colour. When someone is excited about shooting something, especially if it has to be done quickly, diver markers may never enter the minds of the sealers.
In all fairness to sealers, they are just like anyone else...there are yahoos, and there are sensible individuals. Some of these guys (albeit, perhaps, the minority) bring lots of alcohol to fuel a day's fun on the water shooting seals (and please don't anyone dare challenge me on this, I've seen it numerous times firsthand).
Unfortunately, perhaps the only way to be completely safe is to avoid diving at this time all together.
P.S. The only other foolproof method is to do what Dive Right in Scuba said above...there's an idea.
 
Slap some of those public saftey diver reflecive stickers across your tank for when you breach :p
 
Even if one were wearing a blaze (hunter) orange hood, it would still be a seal in some sealers' eyes.
I recall an actual incident when I lived in New Brunswick, Canada, a number of years ago. A hunter was charged and convicted (I believe it was manslaughter) after shooting another man in the head as he was driving his truck (I believe it was a Nissan Pathfinder) down a woods road. The hunter was on a hillside and saw a brown object moving through the trees (which was the truck obscured by trees driving down the woods road). Because it was brown and moving, he thought it resembled a walking deer (which is what he was hunting at the time), and decided it deserved a bullet. It actually got the poor man in the head, I remember seeing pictures of the truck, window out, with blood on the head rest and seat. It was a case of "shoot first, ask questions later".
What a moron, to say the least. And the truth of it is, there are many morons with trigger-happy fingers, both on land and on water. A brown moving truck becomes a walking deer...a bobbing diver with a black hood becomes a seal.
 
ew, well I guess hte moral is your just taking the risk and there isnt a whole lot you can do to protect yourself from crazy hunting *******s like Dick Cheney
 
DivetheRock:
See, this is the problem. There are usually buoys everywhere in the water. Some for fishing nets, some for markers, etc. Another buoy or something floating in the water probably won't mean a whole lot, even if it is a "loud" colour. When someone is excited about shooting something, especially if it has to be done quickly, diver markers may never enter the minds of the sealers.
I'll bet that none of them are long and skinny like a sausage, and then you increase your odds even better if you launch it while you are at 15' and then yank on the line multiple times just before surfacing. A long skinny buoy making weird up and down motions is pretty distinctive.
 
Charlie99:
I'll bet that none of them are long and skinny like a sausage, and then you increase your odds even better if you launch it while you are at 15' and then yank on the line multiple times just before surfacing. A long skinny buoy making weird up and down motions is pretty distinctive.

Maybe. For now, the only two possibilities I can see that may keep you safe are 1) Support topside, very close, to make it obvious that there are divers in the water (which is not feasible for me, as I'm a shore diver). 2) Stay out of the water all together.
You're right, though, Charlie99. A sausage would perhaps be the best choice of all. Once again, though, do I feel safe just because a coloured sausage is bobbing around?...Not really. Seals are often shot from a distance, using binoculars to spot them. Seals have been known to hang around and even play with fishing markers. I've seen this with my own two eyes. A moronic shooter might think the sausage is merely a tool used by the seal to help the shooter sight him in. :rofl3:
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom