Bonaire or Guadelope??

[daptonema]

We're living in Jamaica and currently planning our next trip (just been to TCI).
We're off to Cayman Islands and Belize in the next couple of months but wanting to plan a trip later in the year.
We're torn between Bonaire and Guadelope - anyone have any comments/opinions on either of these islands?
Any other suggestions welcomed.
Thanks

[CLEAR BLUE]

We were in Bonaire in November and had a great time! The shore diving is awesome. You can go where you want to whenever you want to. I've never been to Guadalupe but I don't think you could go wrong with Bonaire.