I just realized that you are from Chicago. I was at BIBR last week with a large group from Chicago. I had a good conversation with the group leader and dive shop owner. I'm somewhat sick at the moment and cannot remember her name, and am too lazy to go look it up. Here's the info on the dive shop, though:
Visibility Unlimited Inc. Scuba Center
8752 W. 159th St.
Orland Park, IL 60462
708-460-9515
info@visibilityunlimited.com
www.visibilityunlimited.com
As far as paying a few hundred a head more for AKR, well, if money is not a big deal, I reccomend doing just that. Or see if you can book with Coco View who has an excellent operation, on the south side of the island.
If you want to just dive with few landside amenities, then BIBR is for you.
The bugs are going to be the same no matter where you go. BIBR rakes the sand everyday, and Coco had raked sand when I was there.
The food is all prepared a few feet away from you at the restaurant on the beach. Some of it was fantastic...Lobsters and steak, Filet Mignon, the fish, and then again, they never did get our omelet prepared correctly. They always wanted to put peppers and tomatoes in mine, and cheese in another of our group. Their soups are VERY tasty!
No matter where you stay, though, I reccomend these activities: The shark dive. (Simply amazing!!), got to Mary's Place and see the seahorses, and on your offgas day before you leave, DEFINITELY, MOST DEFINITELY, take the trip to the mainland and go whitewater rafting with Rios Honduras. Ask if David can guide you. It was something I will remember forever. It is so much more than a rafting trip, I promise you! With BIBR there is a one person minimum, no max; and with the other resorts there is a 3 person minimum. (For the rafting)
Good Luck,
Colin Berry