I dive with
Pro Divers.
For a romantic dinner or a lively weekend lunch/brunch or just a few beers on the beach bar I like
Spice Mill on the South-East Peninsula. Always call ahead because it's a 20 minute drive to get there and they sometimes close/open at will depending on mood, weather, season - whatever.
For Indian take-away and Saturday lunch buffet I love
Copper Chimney. Place looks like a dump and caters mostly to med students from India. Indian food by Indian people for Indian people. Awesome food and well priced.
For emergencies I dial 466-5000 (Dominos Pizza) and get a delivery. "Pizza Boys" has a shop close to Marriott that is not that good.
At the Marriott all F&B sucks but the pizza shack and the upmarket Steak House have just acceptable food.
---------- Post added February 16th, 2013 at 07:56 AM ----------
Oh yeah and things to stay away from I guess the same as everywhere: Stay away from tourist traps
Guys who have a baby monkey on their shoulder and want to let you take a picture... People selling useless trinkets nobody needs.
Another thing I forgot to mention: Avis and Hertz suck on this island. I have been disappointed by both too many times. Friends recommend a local car rental called Bulls Eye which I will test soon. Won't link to it until I have had some first hand experience.
One more thing on the topic of driving: You need a local license to drive here but the car rental firm can just sell you a 90-day license (it's a pink piece of cardboard paper...). To obtain such a license you need to show your existing license if it is in English and pay a fee. If your home license is not in English you need to obtain an international license from home and then use that to get the St. Kitts license.
First half of April I should still be here, too so I might see you guys on the Pro Divers boat