Shearwater Petrel, hands down. Even if you never go tech, it is an awesome computer, and while not cheap, certainly within reasonable range. I saw one for $650 at a dive show, and the Petrel 1 (without the compass) is probably available cheaper now.
Leaving aside everything tech related, this is a great computer because of (1) the very bright and readable display, (2) the tank-like construction, (3) the user replaceable AA battery, and (4) Shearwater's customer service, which is second to none.
Do a search here - you won't find many posts saying bad things about the Petrel. If readability is very important to you and if you can afford it, it's the best, IMHO. Some people rule it out if they absolutely have to have wireless air integration, but the OP said that that wasn't necessary. I don't use WAI at all, I have a Suunto Vyper Air that I never use any more, found WAI to be unreliable and I have no problem with an analog SPG.