We have only had our current steed, a Outrage 190 Boston Whaler for a few years. Our previous boats including inflatible sorts all had things we liked and disliked but this time we specifically went for a center console based on our years of wishing we had one. Grass is always greener on the other side--lol.
The center console is the thouroughbred, no nonsesne, stripped for action boat that is very popular these days and originaly popularized by Boston Whaler. But most all of these open skiff type boats share a common profile, open decks, deep vee or modified vee hulls, outboard powered. A 20 foot boat will compromise some things. I don't like more than three and really just me and my wife on ours and I don't like people dropping their gear on my expensive deck!!!!! Two divers plus four tanks is easy with two crew, three divers and six tanks is possible with one crew. Four would really be a crowd for a long run but for a quick single tank dunk it would be OK.
For warm weather playing then the center console rules, if your going out in the cold that cuddy might be useful but on a small boat it will be cramped and little used.
We see our little boat as a play toy. I am quite confident it could carry me 23 miles offshore to dive the Oriskany or run much further but mostly it is for quick dashes out to dive and fish and run around in.
Quote from BW:
"Also in 1961, Fisher and his team shocked the industry with another innovation - the center console design. This design moved the helm from the starboard side to the center of the craft, providing better steering control and an even keel. The center console boat was more versatile and roomier than its predecessors. It has since blossomed into an $85 million industry."
N