Welcome to ScubaBoard, an online scuba diving forum community where you can join over 205,000 divers diving from around the world. If the topic is related to scuba diving, this is the place to find divers talking about it. To gain full access to ScubaBoard (and make this large box go away) you must register for a free account. As a registered member you will be able to:
Participate in over 500 dive topic forums and browse from over 5,500,000 posts.
Communicate privately with other divers from around the world.
Post your own photos or view from well over 100,000 user submitted images.
Gain access to our free classifieds marketplace to buy, sell and trade gear, travel and services.
Use the calendar to organize your events and enroll in other members' events.
Find a dive buddy or communicate directly with scuba equipment manufacturers.
All this and much more is available to you absolutely free when you register for an account, so sign up today!
If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact the ScubaBoard Support Team.
How much is too much resistance on air draw into the compressor? I built a nitrox stick 2”x 24” basically the Oxyhacker’s design (great book). I know there is going to be some resistance, but while breathing through it I can really feel the difference when I unplug the ½” part on the tee where the sensor screws in. I know there has been hundreds of these built with probably little to no compressor problems. I have a Coltri MCH16 Compact and running a 1 ¼” corrugated hose to the stick. Just curious.
We use 2" hose to feed from our Nitrox generator and that is under pressure. I think that you should go with the largest hose you can get (within reason) since back pressure will cause the first stage to heat up. In the Compact, you really don't want the added heat because the sound deadening also acts a little like an insulator.
how long of a hose are you using
without looking it up how large of a compressor 3 cu ft.
i have a rix 6 and am using the factory sized 3/4 id " i think and it is pumping fine the hose is 10 ft or so. my stick has no resistance that i can tell,,, however the restriction to 1/2 and being partially blocked by the sensor may be of some concern. i am guessing that you have perhaps too many restrictions n the like. can you get a pvc piece (for your sensor) that the hose can be put inside of instead of around? you can eliminate 2 restrictions that way.
Originally Posted by dchango
How much is too much resistance on air draw into the compressor? I built a nitrox stick 2”x 24” basically the Oxyhacker’s design (great book). I know there is going to be some resistance, but while breathing through it I can really feel the difference when I unplug the ½” part on the tee where the sensor screws in. I know there has been hundreds of these built with probably little to no compressor problems. I have a Coltri MCH16 Compact and running a 1 ¼” corrugated hose to the stick. Just curious.
Thanks for the quick responses. The opening in the back will only fit 1 ¼’ or smaller hose. I used the corrugated hose because it had a larger inside diameter then the other hoses that I found. The intake filter housing only has roughly a ¾” opening on it. I had to use a bushing and make it bigger to accommodate the 1 ¼” hose. I am running about 10’ of hose from the compressor to the stick and the compressor is a 9 CFM. Thanks Damon
the 9cfm exlplains the large intake hose. is it safe to assume the 1 1/4 is outside diameter? that makes the id near 1". you can always shorten the hose to a min length and use the largest fitting on the output of the stick to accomodate the hose. it is troubling that you get a significant resistance with the sampling T in the line. T T is where i think you need tomake the major change at.
The opening in the back will only fit 1 ¼’ or smaller hose.
Hmmm ... the last MCH16 Cabinet that I worked with had several knockouts under the foam to work with. The 2" hose was no problem to pass through the rectangular knockout.
Oh ... also make sure that your inlet filter on the stick is rated for the proper flow.
Ray there is only one hole in the back of the unit. I measured the ID of the hose and it measures1 ½” not 1 ¼” as I stated before. The hose barb that I used on the bottom ofthe stick is a 1 ¼”. Peter I haven’t hooked up the O2 meter to it yet, as I’m still in the process of building that too. This all is a work in process. Thanks
Damon
Well, I finally got it completed. I started over completely. Instead of using the 2 inch PVC pipe, I used a 4 inch ABS pipe. The other modification to the stick was rather than using baffles I used practice golf balls with the holes in them. I filled the stick up about three quarters of the way it took 48 golf balls. At first, I just used the golf balls, but noticed it made a direct path going all the way through which I could see through to the bottom of the stick. Being inside the pipe was round and the golf balls were round they fit evenly and made a clear path going through. I decided that I would use some pieces of wire mesh and layer the golf balls. Being the golf balls are not stacked on top of each other now there was no straight path through the stick (I even crushed a few just so they were not completely round).
I finished assembling the stick. I then tested the resistance in the stick by breathing through it again, there was little to no resistance that was in the other stick. I felt that I was on the right track now. I plumbed the stick back to the compressor with some corrugated pool hose, which is about 10 feet long. I also completed my El Cheapo II analyzer (which was also fun to build). I set the meter to 20.9 and fired up the compressor. The meter didn't move it still read 20.9, which was a good sign. The next test was to pump some 02 through it without it blowing up. I cracked the valve and started increasing the flow and watched the meter start going up. I had one of my fill whips cracked open with my other meter analyzing the gas coming out. I got it up to 32% on the stick meter and the meter on the whip read 31.6. Which I'm happy with that, so I think my little project was a success. I can't wait to start pumping some nitrox, I will try to post a picture of it. Thanks for all your help.
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Reply With Quote
Originally Posted by dchango
. I cracked the valve and started increasing the flow and watched the meter start going up. I had one of my fill whips cracked open with my other meter analyzing the gas coming out. I got it up to 32% on the stick meter and the meter on the whip read 31.6. Which I'm happy with that, so I think my little project was a success. I can't wait to start pumping some nitrox, I will try to post a picture of it. Thanks for all your help.