Welcome to ScubaBoard, an online scuba diving forum community where you can join over 205,000 divers diving from around the world. If the topic is related to scuba diving, this is the place to find divers talking about it. To gain full access to ScubaBoard (and make this large box go away) you must register for a free account. As a registered member you will be able to:

  • Participate in over 500 dive topic forums and browse from over 5,500,000 posts.
  • Communicate privately with other divers from around the world.
  • Post your own photos or view from well over 100,000 user submitted images.
  • Gain access to our free classifieds marketplace to buy, sell and trade gear, travel and services.
  • Use the calendar to organize your events and enroll in other members' events.
  • Find a dive buddy or communicate directly with scuba equipment manufacturers.

All this and much more is available to you absolutely free when you register for an account, so sign up today!

NEW for 2014 Access SBlogbook for members. It allows you to directly upload data from your dive computer, validate your logs digitally, link your dives to photos, videos, dive centers (9,000 on file), fishes (14,000 on file) and much more.

If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact the ScubaBoard Support Team.
  • Snapper Ledge would benefit from no-take status - FREE e-Book

    A DIVE TIME Column
    by Tim Grollimund

    When I moved to the Keys, I only knew a few people. You could count the number on one hand. These same folks are very close friends now - even after they’ve gotten to know me better! And I have developed some other very close friendships. Not only with people, but with a few places. I’ve told you about them - the deep sections of the reefs, the south end of Molasses and the pillar coral spot. All these are very special places. Why do I keep going back? Because they are places I can count on for unique and continuously good stuff to see.

    And there is one more spot - Snapper Ledge. There is a petition to have Snapper Ledge set aside as a no-take zone. I support it. If you have been there, you know it’s unique. It’s a very small area, probably less than the size of a football field. Some people want to set it aside, and some don’t. We all have our reasons. The petition is worded to elevate the merits of the site as a haven for fish and divers, and uses language that fisher persons - spear and hook - probably don’t like. I wouldn’t if I were a fisher person. The Sanctuary Advisory Council meeting is August 16th, 9AM at the Marathon Garden Club, 5270 Overseas Highway. The petition is here: www.PetitionOnline.com/snapledg/petition.html. Here is a video that supports the effort: www.vimeo.com/1861001 and a link to PDF file you can download: www.mpa.gov/sciencestewardship/mpascience/

    So, wording notwithstanding, and as I am curious by nature, I started looking into this whole concept of marine protected areas (MPAs) and no-take zones (nMPA). And I found Dr. Ben Halpern of the University of California. He is an expert in the field, and has worked with the state of California to implement a network of MPAs along their coast. There are species concerns, spatial concerns, habitat concerns - everybody’s concerned.

    We talked about a couple of studies he’s done. The first addresses the basic question - do no-take MPAs work? And does size matter? Well, yes they do in fact increase biomass, density and size of the fish inside the protected area for most species. No argument there. And some of you will be relieved to know that size does not matter. The scale may be different - 100 to 200 fish versus 1000 to 2000; but nMPAs of all sizes work - inside the boundaries.

    So the second question was do they work outside of the protected area - is there spillover, and if so, how much? Yes, there is - and here is a very interesting point, which I believe helps make the case for Snapper Ledge. It seems as though a series - or network - of small to medium-sized nMPAs may work better than one large one. But as is always the case, there are complications. Habitat, structure, depth, and other variables all enter the fray. A strategically placed network of small to medium-sized nMPAs can override the loss of fishing territory and result in a net gain in the yield of fish to the entire area, according to Dr. Halpern - but not for all species. There are places where the give-up of fishing space is less than compensated for by the increase in fish from the spillover from the nMPA. Each place is different - Dr. Halpern said they spent years and tons of bucks taking all that into consideration - and they did it at the state level within their 3 mile zone. But we have federal requirements, not just state, so strap yourself in - this is going to take a while.

    Here is an interesting case in point - a study on the Dry Tortugas a few years back. Google “Bulletin of Marine Science 633-654 2006” and you can see this for yourself. I’ll just skip to the ending: “In the long run, a precautionary ecosystem-based approach to management using multiple control methods offers promise for providing fishery sustainability and persistence of the Florida Keys coral-reef ecosystem... combining catch controls with large closed areas may be the most effective system of reducing risk of stock collapse while maintaining short- and long-term economic performance and buffering uncertainty.” That says it all.

    To get the big picture of what it will take to make Snapper Ledge a no-take zone, I had the privilege of talking with Sean Morton, Superintendent of the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary. He was very familiar with Dr. Halpern’s work, and he explained the process from the FKNMS viewpoint. Sanctuary regulations, which can be drafted by the South Atlantic Fisheries Management Council in conjunction with FKMNS, go through an extensive public process prior to the regulations being published in the Federal Register. The Snapper Ledge request will be part of an all-encompassing package from Biscayne to the Dry Tortugas, including the backcountry. Add to that all the studies and data required to support the requests. Because user groups have a chance to examine the documents and comment on the proposals, waiting periods for comments come into play. This will most likely be a two to three year process. Sean explained the process, but we don’t have the space here for all the details. It is a massive project when all the elements are taken into consideration.

    Paradigms shift. Conditions change. We don’t have a crystal ball. We do have a small area that can be preserved, and we will not know if the net reduction in fish caught or speared will be offset by the future increase in life generated by making Snapper Ledge a no-take zone. Only time will tell. I’d like to give it a shot - with a camera, not a spear.

    Tim Grollimund is a freelance photographer and PADI divemaster based in Key Largo. He can be reached at tim@timgimages.com or through his web site at www.timgimages.com. Keep tabs on his activity for the Coral Restoration Foundation at www.timgimages.com/crlogbook.

    Download the Free e-book

  • Sponsored by:

  • Recent Blog Posts:


    Crowley's Blog - Living the Dream, Part 7 - Seriously Unimpressed

    I had to take a few days out after the Rescue course because as I mentioned in the previous chapter, I couldn’t actually walk properly for a couple of days due to the fact that I hadn’t done that...

    Crowley June 24th, 2015 08:45 AM
    Planet Scuba Mexico

    Cavern & Cave Diving in Mexico's Cenotes

    When it's time for a dive vacation again we all have our specific and individual preferences. Some prefer exotic dive destinations such as Indonesia or Cocos Islands whereas some rather stick to...

    Planet Scuba Mexico June 17th, 2015 01:02 AM

    Crowley's Blog - Living the Dream, Part 6 - Help! Help!

    The Rescue Diver course is often described in the PADI literature as “the first step to becoming a dive professional” and ever since I took my own rescue course, I have to say that I very much...

    Crowley June 16th, 2015 01:49 PM

    GoPro Book Ad... tells you what you can learn for under twenty bucks

    peterbucknell June 15th, 2015 09:49 PM

    Brinyte June New Arrival Dive Flashlight

    [FONT=arial][SIZE=3]Summer of the Northern Hemisphere has arrived, it’s an happy and cool thing to do water sports now! Let’s see Brinyte newest diving flashlight which will be selling in June.

    brinyte June 14th, 2015 11:36 PM
  • What do you think?:

    What is your biggest challenge when diving? (Votes: 200)

    1. Wetsuit sizing (Votes: 51)

    2. BC sizing (Votes: 27)

    3. Weight of tank/back problems (Votes: 61)

    4. Bust support (Votes: 3)

    5. Tangled hair (Votes: 46)

    6. Staying warm in the water (Votes: 42)

    7. Staying warm above water (Votes: 14)

    8. Fashion (Colors/Designs) (Votes: 6)

    9. Fin sizing (Votes: 9)

    10. Dry Suit sizing (Votes: 21)

    11. Skin care/Sun protection (Votes: 10)

    12. Other (Votes: 30)

    Are you allowed to dive solo? Please elaborae in comments (Votes: 110)

    1. I have SDI solo diver certificaion and have always been allowed to dive solo (Votes: 17)

    2. I have SDI solo diver certification but have been denied the ability to dive solo (Votes: 9)

    3. I have PADI self reliant diver certification and have always been allowed to dive solo (Votes: 2)

    4. I have PADI self reliant diver certification but have been denied the abiltiy to dive solo (Votes: 1)

    5. I am not solo certified and have always been able to dive solo (Votes: 66)

    6. I am not solo certified and have been denied the ability to dive solo (Votes: 15)

    Do you use a Mesh Protector? (Votes: 14)

    1. I never use a mesh protector (Votes: 12)

    2. I only use a mesh protector to transport my tanks (Votes: 2)

    3. I keep the mesh protector on at all times - even while I dive (Votes: 0)

    4. I use something else to protect my tanks (Votes: 0)

    I caught the crud (Votes: 4)

    1. Yes and I'm a diver (Votes: 3)

    2. Yes but I'm a non-diver (Votes: 1)