My favorite dive place might not be yours, but okay...
We keep going back to Roatan's CoCoView, sometimes twice a year, usualy for two weeks at a crack.
Is that the only place? Heavens, no, but
it is "home".
Since our last visit to CCV we have also been to Galapagos, Tobago, Sharm Red Sea, Philippines, Bonaire, Nekton and in a whole lot of July afternoon pools here with children in the midwest!
CoCoView is the kind of place that people adopt as a second home. It just feels good. It is a diver's resort- no illusions of Cozumel/Cancun/Cayman. You go there to dive, and dive you will.
You'll be surrounded by old hands who will gladly offer thoughts if asked, they will show you the cool microscopic critters that the South side of the island is noted for. The dive staff is very long term and you'll get to the point where you'll know their families and by bringing down gifts for their specific children.
The boats are aces. A center cut moon well for easy access in pitching seas. They are exceedingly camera friendly. The wet rooms are intelligently laid out and access to the boats and the resorts is close to 100% handicapped accessable. You might not be in a wheelchair, but as you get older...
The rooms are fun as they are out on posts over an active changing reef. The food is good and fattening and tasty. No shortage of it, either.
The best resort based shore dive in the Caribbean, and I've pretty well seen them all. 200' offshore of your room, follow the anchor chain out from 3 feet of water, explore the 140' tanker (Prince Albert Wreck), sitting upright in 35>65fsw, or wander off to the DC3 aircraft. Meet the critters- above and below the water.
We go to a lot of places, CoCoView is home.
www.cocoviewresort.com and the bulletin board is
http://www.websitetoolbox.com/tool/mb/ccv, but the webcam can really make you homesick:
http://www.cocoviewresort.com/cam.html