January is the peak season in the Caribbean and it will very hard to find a great diving at a low price. Since the diving experience is your most important criteria, have you considered a liveaboard dive trip?
At first glance a liveaboard may seem expensive but most of them are all-inclusive and when you figure out the cost-per-dive they are usually much cheaper than a land-based dive trip with boat diving. Plus they usually dive the most pristine, less frequently visited sites.
The Caribbean Explorer offers a Saba and St. Kitts dive trip out of St. Martin that leaves on January 10. I doubt if you will be able to find a discount price in January, and the rate listed is higher than you are looking for, but it includes just about everything: accommodations, up to 5 dives per day including night dives, food and beverages (alcoholic and non-alcoholic). And the diving is usually very easy, you just set up your gear one time, the crew refills your tank in place, and you just put it on and step off the boat at the next mooring.
The Explorer is a very good liveaboard operation and there is great diving around Saba - it is a beautiful and interesting island.
Saba, St. Kitts, St. Maarten - Caribbean Explorer II
On main and lower decks, each with private ensuite
$1,895
Plus: port/hotel, immigration and Marine Park fees of $115 and fuel surcharge payable on board; transfers.
Package includes:
7 nights/8 days aboard the vessel; up to 5 dives daily (weather permitting);
3 meals daily, except Friday’s evening meal; between-dive snacks; towels, linens, etc.; use of tanks, weights and weight belts; all air fills; alcohol and non-alcoholic beverages.
The Northeastern Caribbean is an intriguing area offering a blend of Dutch, British, French and native cultures on some of the most scenic islands of the Caribbean.
The vessel departs Saturday's from either St. Maarten or St. Kitts. Itineraries include 5 1/2 days of diving; 2 to 3 days within the Saba Marine Park, and 2 to 3 days at St. Kitts. 5 dives daily are normally offered, including night dives. The schedule also provides for up to 3 island tours during the week, there is ample time for our guests to explore forts, rainforests, duty-free shops and museums.
The Northeastern Caribbean itinerary, combining diving and optional island access, has always been unique within the liveaboard diving industry. As a dedicated dive liveaboard, all diving is done directly off of the vessel, using the expansive dive deck covering the aft third of the main deck. Each diver has his or her own dive gear bin; a large camera table, as well as rinse tanks, wetsuit drying racks, charging stations are available for all to use.
Nitrox is available; tanks are filled in place between each dive, so that there is never any need to disassemble your gear. If you are interested in touring the islands, other guests' can continue diving. We can also arrange additional time ashore to hike the rainforest-covered mountains, horseback ride on the beach, or even play golf, check with the crew when you board.
A variety of specialty course training is available aboard, if you are desiring to take a specific course with us, please let us know when making your reservation. Complete dive gear and computer rental are also available.