San Andres and/or Old Providence are often over look Caribbean destinations. Being some of the southern most Caribbean island, so usually safe from hurricanes. Depending on what you like,
San Andres is more a tourist place with resorts casinos, disco Tec, beaches, diving and dining.
Old Providence is more a nature preserve with dry rain forest, mangrove preserve, deserted beaches, 3rd largest reef in the world, small cabanas type resorts. The locals love and respect there nature wonderland so you wont find night clubs, casino or large resorts.
I have a group going in Aug 30 thru Sept 6 if you’re interested check out my web page.
Ciao
Tad