Working on planning the next annual guy's dive trip. We're trying to do something new. Previous trips have included Bonaire, Grand Cayman, Cozumel, Belize (mediocre except Blue Hole).

Potential destinations that we are thinking about are:
1) Roatan
2) Curacao
3) Little Cayman

Factors that we weigh:

1) Dive quality
2) Travel Options (ideally from Atlanta, but we're all over the place)
3) Night life (for a couple of the guys)
4) Cost

The trips have generally been for 4 days of diving. We did Bonaire for a week, but also only got 3 people who could go for that long.

Your vote? (and reason why)

Thanks,
Dave