Thal, you are correct. Since the topic of this thread is basically concerning the training of basic recreational diving instructors, I did need you to type more clearly to understand that you were comparing your 100 hour SH University Research Diving students with every one else's basic recreational open water diving students.
To me that's also kind of like how you compared multi billion dollar competitive sports/entertainment industries with the recreational dive hobby world.
That only goes to show how unfamiliar you are with the students that participate in the 100 hour programs as well as with the history of diving instruction and the historic development and changes in recreational diving instruction.
That type of miscommunication is one reason I questioned your participation in a thread on the training of basic recreational dive instructors, that and the fact that you really have no involvement with today's basic recreational dive training.
Question all that you want, it doesn't change the fact that the standards that one of the major agencies operates under, from skin diver up through instructor, stand virtually unchanged from the 1980s when, under contract to them, I wrote those them. I think just that is sufficient credential to permit in the door on this conversation.
From the way you type I get the feeling you are looking forward to the collapse of most of todays basic recreational diving industry, even though many of your neighbors who will see their lifelong dreams and work destroyed are not really the used car salesman types you seem to believe every one in today's basic recreational diving industry is. But at least then you will be proven right, no matter how many people suffer.
I don't really think that I have that kind of power. I do think that a major realignment is coming, and I expect that it will favor the long term independent instructor, rather than the dive shop, and yes ... I'd welcome that change as the best thing FOR THE WOULD-BE-DIVER.
I truly thought you thought your average student bought more gear than Joe Angelo's average student, or Joe Dituri's average student, or Bill Rennaker's average student. I truly don't know but it's possible your students go on to buy doubles, scooters, rebreathers, housings, etc., and then they could be similar in gear purchase to instructor trainers students or cave instructor's students, but even so I saw you as standing on the Empire State building pounding your chest at all the insects on the streets far below.
You have a vivid imagination.
One of my most cherished moments here on SB was in a thread where I chided you for using kid gloves on me and you responded that you didn't want to offend me because you respected my input or opinion or some such. Well if you really do respect my opinion then think about the fact that as one of the only close to true zero to hero graduates that does not hide that fact here on SB, I get PM's from quite a few others who just don't post in these threads and hide the facts around their instructor cert, because of the 800 pound gorillas on the sky scrapers. I'm betting there are many others.
People can survive and prosper and grow in spite of many things, but for you to pretend that you were a zero-to-hero creation (you started diving at what? Age 6 or 7? As did I) is a bit on the specious side. I was teaching diving long before I ever attended an ITC and (for me) the major function of the ITC was to expand my network and to gain a new and very capable mentor. So I went from someone who's only previous credential was a NAUI Basic Diver card (with no open water dives) to an Instructor in the course of two weeks (though I'd been diving for almost twenty years at stage) ... is that zero-to-hero too?
Since I have only recently drifted out of the Hawaii O'hana and Photo forums I have often wondered why there is no REAL presence here from the agency the vast majority of basic recreational divers get introduced to diving by, but the recent activity in this thread and reading between the lines in the bashing thread has certainly ended that wondering. I for one hope we do not lose ANY relevant source of enlightenment and welcome OceanEd to continued gainful discussion.
PADI's corporate philosophy, as explained to me by a past CEO, is never to fight the battle, even if it is the good fight, but rather to be sure to take the money. I too welcome OceanEd to SB, he will (IMHO) raise the level of the conversation no end.