I just remember that is was discussed, the comment being that it was just not effective, and no longer to be attempted.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
I just remember that is was discussed, the comment being that it was just not effective, and no longer to be attempted.
In that case either you are misremembering, or that instructor was really crappy and not teaching to standards. In water CPR has not been part of the PADI Rescue class for at least 15 years, if ever. Not an opinion, a verifiable fact.PADI, and 6 years ago now I believe.
In-water rescue breaths can be effective. So is there a current consensus as to rescue breaths while towing? Decisions modified by pulse/no pulse, 1 rescuer versus two or more, quick vs longer tow to boat/land. There should be some objective agreement.
The underlying criterion is delay time before CPR can commence. Long delays are not good. 5 mins is the breakpoint. If the delay will be long, then rescue breathes might help, so you give them for 1-2 mins and check for responsiveness. If positive reaction to breaths, continue breaths while towing to shore. If no response, tow as fast as possible to get to CPR. PADI says, "The potential disadvantage of giving rescue breaths is that if the victim is in cardiac arrest it may delay starting CPR. There is limited research that suggests the advantages outweigh this potential disadvantage."In-water rescue breaths can be effective. So is there a current consensus as to rescue breaths while towing? Decisions modified by pulse/no pulse, 1 rescuer versus two or more, quick vs longer tow to boat/land. There should be some objective agreement.