Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
Good advice. One of the things I like about the Hydros Pro I use is that I can swap out the integrated weight pockets for the "Trav-Tek" straps when I travel for tropical diving. Since I only need 4 lbs when diving warm ocean water, I just toss that in the trim pockets and I'm good to go with a BCD that is lighter and less bulky for traveling.It also depends where you plan to do most of your diving.
I use a lightweight folding back inflate travel BC in the tropics (Scubapro Lighthawk ) and a Diverite BP/wing if I am doing cold water diving.
The lightweight is IMO perfect for tropical travel and as it is back inflate, good for underwater photography.
Your suggestion to try out a number of options is a good one. Don't be in a rush to purchase and don't limit yourself to only what the LDS sells.
I was a swimmer/water polo player/lifeguard before getting into diving. I worked my way through the various types of BCs and ended up with the most basic option of a BP/W and webbing harness. I really enjoy the feeling of freedom in the water from a minimal setup. It's the closest I can get to my childhood dreams of being able to swim like Aquaman.I'm quite comfortable in the water, I'm a swimmer and open water swimmer so getting water in my face is fine. I don't think that being pushed forward will be a problem, especially if it's easy to avoid.
I agree.However, there is trope that you cannot trim properly in a jacket BC. I believe this is incorrect. It may need more work to do, but you can trim out.
I think people who backpack see a need for shoulder pads until they realize that the only time there is any weight on the shoulders is when they are getting in and out of the water.I have never found the need for shoulder pads.
And even then, these are 2" (50mm) wide straps. They distribute the weight pretty well even without pads.I think people who backpack see a need for shoulder pads until they realize that the only time there is any weight on the shoulders is when they are getting in and out of the water.