Buoyancy Cruise Control

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

DeepSeaDan

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Messages
1,095
Reaction score
280
Location
Ontario, Canada
# of dives
I'm a Fish!
Now here is a nifty little idea/item to take care of all those pesky buoyancy issues; not sure about trim though! Further, a malfunction might be worrisome...

Tell us what you think...



"Anatoly Kudryashov Breathe New Life Department of Mechanical Engineering Jenny Xu Rob Earl University of Auckland Vojislav Kecman buoyancy control device
(16 October 2008)

16 October 2008 - An Electronic Dive Buddy built by University of Auckland engineering students could make scuba diving a much safer sport.

Anatoly Kudryashov and Jenny Xu from the Department of Mechanical Engineering's Mechatronics Engineering specialisation have designed a computerised system to automatically adjust a diver's buoyancy if they get into trouble. The project was supervised by Associate Professor Vojislav Kecman and assisted by Technical Officer Rob Earl.

"The most important task for a diver while underwater is buoyancy control. Normally this is controlled manually by adding or releasing air in a buoyancy control device, which is worn like a jacket," Anatoly says.

"To rise in the water, a diver adds air to the buoyancy control device. To sink, air is let out. If the buoyancy is not adjusted correctly, a diver may rise too rapidly or descend too quickly to an unsafe depth, risking serious injury or sometimes death," Jenny says.

The Electronic Dive Buddy attaches to the buoyancy jacket and monitors the diver's motion while underwater. It automatically adjusts buoyancy if an unsafe depth or velocity is reached. The device also has a 'cruise control' feature, allowing divers to automatically maintain a desired depth in the water.

Anatoly, who is in avid diver, couldn't understand why computer control hadn't been introduced to scuba diving and decided to tackle the problem as part of his assessment for a Bachelor of Engineering Degree. Mechatronics Engineering students work in pairs to complete a major research project in their final year of study.

The Electronic Dive Buddy prototype was tested in the laboratory and in a 4.7 metre deep swimming pool.

"Our tests so far have proven the device to work, so the next step is to look at its marketability. As far as I know, a device like this does not exist," Anatoly says.

Anatoly and Jenny presented their findings at The Department of Mechanical Engineering project display day on Friday, 10 October 2008. The students received an IPENZ Award for the quality of their presentation and display."


Myself - I'll stick to manual control; after all, it is pretty easy to do with proper training & practice.

Best,
DSD
 
"To rise in the water, a diver adds air to the buoyancy control device."

Anyone else have a problem with this?
 
"To rise in the water, a diver adds air to the buoyancy control device."

Anyone else have a problem with this?

Yup. Assuming neutral buoyancy, a little deeper breath and you'll start up, and then you'd better start dumping.

Unless, that is, you have that new-fangled computer-automatic-diver-buoyancy-control-thingy that will do all the diving for you. Maybe it'll start you up when it reads from your computer that you're low on gas (get you back to the boat with 500psi) or nearing your NDL, and you'll get a readout on your HUD telling you it has called the dive . Maybe a little thump up icon...:shakehead:
 
"To rise in the water, a diver adds air to the buoyancy control device."

Anyone else have a problem with this?

Heh, I was thinking the same thing when I read it. I actually had to go back and re-read it to make sure I was understanding what was being said. I'm curious if the guy really is an "avid diver" but really had no clue what's going on....or if he's an "internet diver" who has read some stuff and just assumed that you add/release air to your BC and use it as an elevator...
 
^^ Many people actually do use their BCD as an elevator. Hell, I think Mares even released a BCD with an UP/DOWN lever.

I agree. It's worrisome. It's one thing to have something beep at you when it thinks you are moving too fast. It's something else entirely to have a device that physically changes your motion.

No thanks. I'll keep using my lungs.
 
"To rise in the water, a diver adds air to the buoyancy control device."

Anyone else have a problem with this?

Oh yeah. They are going to create the super yo-yo of the deep.
 
Forgetting about the details, this seems to be a complicated solution to a non-problem. Moreover it would probably create more harm than good, since it increases diver dependency on a device as opposed to developing skills.

After some experience, most divers have no problem managing bouyancy about as well as they can balance a bicycle. It becomes instinctive and is done with almost no conscious effort. If they used this device, they'd become dependent on it, their skills would atrophy and they'd by up the creek if it were to fail (and like all devices, it will).
 
I just am not a big fan of electronics taking control like that. What happens if it malfunctions? What happens if it missreads an action? Plus that will be more of a reason for a diver to go complacent and not pay attention. Good idea, just not something I would trust.
 
Yup. Assuming neutral buoyancy, a little deeper breath and you'll start up, and then you'd better start dumping.

Unless, that is, you have that new-fangled computer-automatic-diver-buoyancy-control-thingy that will do all the diving for you. Maybe it'll start you up when it reads from your computer that you're low on gas (get you back to the boat with 500psi) or nearing your NDL, and you'll get a readout on your HUD telling you it has called the dive . Maybe a little thump up icon...:shakehead:

We can add a GPS and an integrated DPV then pre-program the entire dive. All you have to do is strap in and breath.

dkktsunami,

"super yo-yo of the deep"
rofl
 
"To rise in the water, a diver adds air to the buoyancy control device."

Anyone else have a problem with this?

Sounds like a surefire uncontrolled rapid ascent to me.
 

Back
Top Bottom