Question about death of Edward Cossaboom, 1914

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Jake

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Divemaster
Messages
499
Reaction score
87
Location
CA
# of dives
200 - 499
Hopefully this is the right forum; if not, maybe mods can be so kind as to move this post.

Warning: this post might also count as a little graphic.

In his book "Dark Descent," Kevin F. McMurray describes the death of hard hat diver Edward Cossaboom who was doing salvage work on the recently sunk Empress of Ireland. I don't quite understand the physics of his death and was hoping someone could shed some light on the situation.

While doing his work, Cossaboom lost his footing at 75 feet and fell to the riverbed at 140 feet. His tenders weren't able to respond in time and the pressure differential shoved most of him up into the helmet:

By the time he hit the bottom the invading sea pressure had stripped the flesh from his bones. His skin and organs were pile-driven into the only part of his suit that was resistant to the pressure, his copper diving helmet.
McMurray explains that by breathing gas at ambient pressure we maintain enough internal pressure in our blood and organs to avoid being crushed. Free divers and other mammals routinely dive well below 140 feet without matching ambient pressure, and bodies are commonly recovered below that depth without having imploded. McMurray's explanation of needing to match ambient pressure therefore seems incomplete with respect to what happened to Cossaboom.

So...what am I missing? Does the helmet and the air supply hose in this situation really present that much of a pressure differential when adding 2ATM of pressure?
 
Thanks @Julius SCHMIDT. I was definitely just overthinking it, but I guess I'm still surprised that 2atm of change is enough to do that to someone. Hopefully he went quickly, as that does not sound like a fun way to go if it's slow.
 
Even in a tight fitting neoprene drysuit it's not pretty think of a machine with claws grabbing your inner thigh x10
 
The same phenomenon is responsible for "mask squeeze", usually in new divers who are overwhelmed, holding their nose trying to clear their ears. The mask space doesn't equalize and they get 2 black eyes or blood vessels in their sclera break and they have some blood in there. 2ATA is quite a bit of pressure, plenty to cause mask squeeze, or kill Cossaboom
Scuba Dive Mask Squeeze — Medical Dive Article — DAN | Divers Alert Network
 
Thanks @Julius SCHMIDT. I was definitely just overthinking it, but I guess I'm still surprised that 2atm of change is enough to do that to someone. Hopefully he went quickly, as that does not sound like a fun way to go if it's slow.

Hmm... Say average surface area of a human is 3000 in^2. Times 14psi = 84,000 pounds of pressure, pushing against the only opening - say a 1" air fitting - 0.79 in^2 area.

Math is probably wrong, but you get the idea...
 
Hmm... Say average surface area of a human is 3000 in^2. Times 14psi = 84,000 pounds of pressure, pushing against the only opening - say a 1" air fitting - 0.79 in^2 area.

Math is probably wrong, but you get the idea...

When you put it that way, it's pretty incredible that we don't feel any of that when properly equalized.

Thanks everyone for the replies.
 
Yes it was horrifying! I really thought they would bust that myth and was shocked that it was confirmed, given just the right circumstances.
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom