Andaman Closures?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Nope - we have not heard about any closures to the Koh Tao sites ....

Well there is an article on divernet.com that mentions Chalok Bay and Tanote Bay spelled quite interestingly. Not the most popular divesites, even though nothing beats a good monsoon dive at Viewpoint rock. Here is the link anyway: Thailand could close reefs - Divernet
 
The news paper is hardly an official channel and they usually do get the finer points wrong - particularly given the translation issue too.

Once again - so far - and apart from errant newspaper reports - there has been no official indication that any of the reefs around Koh Tao are to close.
 
I am heading over to Similans on the 28th for a LOB. My dive operator (South Siam Divers) has reassured me that there will be no change of LOB plans.
 
Ayesha, you are right, they struggle with the finer points. German media, TV and print, reported that Similans, Surin, Khao Lak and Phi Phi were all closed for diving. Implying the entire parks not just individual dive sites...

Talk about a blow for the industry.

Inronically they worry about the dive shops undermining the closures and still running LOBs... No word about illegal fishing.
 
I wish the gov't/media would just be more clear in their statements. They should be saying they are closing a number of sites to tourists versus saying they are closing dive sites. The media, especially thai media, are just not interested in the details. They are predominantly closing shallow reefs frequented by snorkelers. My personal, very biased opinion, is that those speed boats full of snorkelers are the biggest disasters in waiting in the Andamans.
 
I am pointing anyone who asks to the Scubaboard forum, lots of good comments on several threads. The main thing is - only a few areas have been closed (have they really, can anyone out in the islands the last few days verify that?) - and those are mostly shallow reefs not used as dive sites. East of Eden we already heard from the start of the season did not look good, and all dive boat staff I spoke to said they were not diving it anyway. We have had just as many happy customers and just as much good feedback as last year. Lots of mantas have helped with that!
 
The Government (Mu Koh Similan National Park) has been very clear in their announcement. Only two dive sites are closed in the Similans.
 
Ko Lanta Dive Sites Unaffected by Closures

All Ko Lanta dive sites remain open after reports that many of Thailand’s top dive sites are to be closed today, due to coral bleaching that occurred at shallow depths during the El Niño period in May 2010.

The director of the Department for National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation in Thailand, Sunan Arunnoparat, announced yesterday that eighteen diving and snorkelling sites, located mainly off the west (Andaman) coast of Thailand, will be closed for up to 14 months to allow coral, damaged by unusually high sea temperatures in May 2010, to recover.
The dramatic move was announced last night following a meeting in Bangkok that included marine biologists and researchers.

Dive sites listed to close lie within 7 of Thailand’s 148 National Parks and include sites within the National Marine Parks of; Ko Surin, Similan, Phi Phi, Petra, Tarutao, Chumphon and Hat Chao Mai.

It’s unclear how individual sites were chosen for closure. Although many of the sites listed are within high-profile marine parks that are famous for attracting large numbers of divers each year, none of the actual sites listed as banned are among the major diving destinations in Thailand.

The two sites listed for closure nearest the Ko Lanta area are, Ko Chuak – sometimes included as part of the popular 4-Island Snorkelling Tour, and Hin Klang – a snorkel site near Ko Phi Phi. All other sites remain open for diving and snorkelling.

Closures are due to begin today (Friday 21st January 2011). Divers or snorkeller breaching these closures could incur penalties of 1,000 – 10,000 THB (equivalent to US$30 – US$300).

An announcement, welcomed by many marine environmentalists, stated that Thai authorities have also vowed to step up patrols to stop illegal fishing and increase moorings at spots not affected by the closures, aimed at reducing damage done by boats anchoring on, or using destructive fishing practices, near reefs. There is no indication as to how these steps will be enforced. For decades, illegal fishing has continued on and around marine parks, even though divers have been calling on the authorities to enforce protection laws.

Many local dive operators in southern Thailand are actively involved in reef monitoring projects in collaboration with Project AWARE, Greenfins and the Phuket Marine Biology Centre in order to study and limit the effects of global warming and coral bleaching.

Diving and snorkelling operators often play a vital role in local communities struggling to cope with growing levels of tourism, communicating reef conservation techniques and environmental awareness to both members of the local community and visiting diving and snorkelling tourists.

There appears to be some controversy in media coverage as to whether or not diving impacts reefs damaged by coral bleaching and why action is being taken so long after the event. Marine conservationists at last night’s meeting, are said to have blamed unregulated tourism – walking on coral, mooring boats over reefs and contaminating the water in the Andaman Sea, a region that draws thousands of tourists each year to enjoy it’s beautiful beaches and reefscapes. Sunan Arunnopparat said global warming was at fault.

It’s unclear why the widespread occurrence of coral bleaching has only just come to the attention of the authorities. Water temperatures right now are actually a degree or two colder than normal for the time of year and reefs located further south in Thai waters are positively flourishing at the moment. Current media coverage seems to incude scant focus on the fact that there are vast areas of coral reef in Thailand that are undamaged or well on their way to recovery, despite the unusually warm water temperatures some 9 months ago.

Coral bleaching is a growing global concern and the fact that the Thai government is taking this phenomenon seriously has got to be a good thing. Whether it’s a step in the right direction or a nail in the coffin of Thailand’s diving industry, action does need to be taken. By raising public awareness we have a better chance of taking the global steps desperately needed to slow down or reverse effects of global warming. It’s a shame that there is not a greater focus on controlling and enforcing illegal practices that would have a far more immediate and tangible benefit to Thailand’s reefs, rather than attempting to overcome mother nature.
 

Back
Top Bottom