comparing cruise lines....??

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Thinking way outside the box here but why would you go to the Caribbean on a cruise boat after you have been there numerous times diving? Nothing changed. Why not try a Alaska cruise or better yet a Viking River cruise from Budapest to Nuremberg or a Normandt France cruise. Not diving so do something different.

Because cruising is it's own luxury. When you have a personal room attendant who greats you by name every day when they see you in the halls. Your dining servers do the same. They remember what you like to drink and will have it waiting for you when you sit down for dinner. You can spend your days in complete relaxation, in whatever ways that means for you. Relax in a pool or hot-tub, lay out in a sun chair, go to the spa, work out in the gym, stay in your room and eat room service (free of charge) all day.

If I could spend my life on a cruise ship I would. You are treated like royalty. Getting to spend you days sailing the Caribbean and seeing beautiful islands makes it even better.
 
Thinking way outside the box here but why would you go to the Caribbean on a cruise boat after you have been there numerous times diving? Nothing changed. Why not try a Alaska cruise or better yet a Viking River cruise from Budapest to Nuremberg or a Normandt France cruise. Not diving so do something different.
agreed. the thread seems to be focused on the caribbean. have you considered other destinations? alaska to vancouver is nice. the baltic is awesome, and a danube river cruise is very interesting (but not a lot of vegetables other than cabbage). you can even go to antarctica.

there are also smaller boutique cruise ships that will provide more personal service (at a higher price point..)

we were in Nassau Bahamas on a corporate boondoggle this spring and saw between 5 and 10 cruise ships pull in each day. i do not think there was much difference among them...the caribbean would not make my cruise destination list.
 
The Caribbean is beautiful, and some people who do mainly dedicated dive trips may not see all that much topside, or at least not indulge some of the interesting sights & activities that the islands offer. Whether a rainforest hike, catamaran coastal tour, zip line, jungle canopy aerial tram or sunning on the beach, or touring historic forts, there's a lot to do besides diving in the Caribbean (don't tell my wife I said that; I like to maximize diving).

A buddy of mine proposed cruising Alaska someday. I suspect there are a couple of kinds of people, get separated out when they see the snow capped mountain tops & alpine forest of the great north - those who are spiritually touched and inspired by the primal majesty of the mountain range & other natural splendor of Alaska, and those of us who'd probably look at it and take snap shots for a half hour or so, decide 'Okay, been there done that, so now what?' My buddy would be one of the former. I'd spend an Alaskan trip continuously aware that I could have been somewhere tropical diving instead. Or at least looking at lush tropical vegetation.

There are places I might like to see if I were retired, well-off and had scads of free time - the Holy Land, parts of Europe such as Rome, for that matter a number of places right here in the U.S. But while I'm working, have just a few weeks a year to divvy up amongst all my entertainment options, and really about 2 weeks to dedicate to vacations focused on me & what I want to do, it's pretty much Florida and the Caribbean.

Richard.
 
We do plan to do an Alaska cruise next year, for our 30th anniversary!
This first trip though... we want it to be as painless as possible, relaxing is the key.... as I said, my husband just had surgery and doesn't want crazy rushed go go go, and probably will not be able to dive this trip regardless.

thanks everyone for your input.... I am leaning more towards Carnival for the trip. We are in our 50s but very active and outgoing. It sounds like this will suit us for the first trip.

robin
 
I've only done small craft (70-100 passenger) eco-cruise ships, having worked on the Lindblad/National Geographic ones for several winters. I like them but they are focused on natural histry and involve a lot of physical activities, and have no entertainment, casinos, etc.

We have had ships from several companies come to Catalina as a destination. Carnival ranks at the bottom IMHO in terms of quality of passengers. I can always tell if one of their ships is in port by the significant increase in smokers on our streets and the trash they leave behind (even when a trash can is 5 ft away). The passengers from Celebrity and RCCL are much better.
 
we have been on over 20 cruises.. we have done RC, Carnival, and NW.

We like carnival the best as we always go with the mother in law and my son.

I also will go against the grain and say that i like the smaller boats better. I really could care less about the fancy art on the walls, etc... I want good service and good food....

the smaller boats give much better service, and i dont feel like cattle.. the larger boats have longer lines, longer waits, etc..

the smaller boats have a much worse crew to passenger ratio.

I enjoy talking to the people working on the boats and they almost all say they like the smaller boats better, and is shows. the crew seems happer on a fantasy class boat.

i do agree that you should get a balcony, no question. it is worth every penny. it adds a whole other room. it is nice to sit out and watch the sun set or come up and have a drink or cup of coffee...

it is also nice for the love life...

destinations are the biggest thing to check..they make or break a cruise.
 
Not counting liveaboards - I have never done a cruise.

Will probably give one of those European River Cruises a go sometime!

Just seems like something I would like.
 
I've only done small craft (70-100 passenger) eco-cruise ships, having worked on the Lindblad/National Geographic ones for several winters. I like them but they are focused on natural histry and involve a lot of physical activities, and have no entertainment, casinos, etc.

We have had ships from several companies come to Catalina as a destination. Carnival ranks at the bottom IMHO in terms of quality of passengers. I can always tell if one of their ships is in port by the significant increase in smokers on our streets and the trash they leave behind (even when a trash can is 5 ft away). The passengers from Celebrity and RCCL are much better.

that is because carnival is the least expensive.

It has gotten worse in the last few years....
i actually heard people telling another group that they did not work and were on assistance and were able to go on the cruise.... WTF??????....

i still like the small carnival ships. We go every year as a gift from my mother inlaw. Since i never look a gift horse in the mouth i go and have a great time.

If i were paying, i would still probably do a carnival..
 
I will be looking forward to your take on Carnival and your experience if that is where you end up.

You better start practicing your belly flop now. :D
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/peregrine/

Back
Top Bottom