EBS: You have not enabled message replies so am re-posting here.
Appreciate your comments on St. J and St. Lucia. Am interested in St. J and in particular Caneel, because of the natural surrounding and laid-back approach they advertise. I've heard, but can't say I have first hand experience, that the Westin is a bit over-done for a relaxing holiday.
Would you disagree?
Am also interested in Lucia. Any recs on accomodations?
I am an experienced diver of 15+ years, while my fiance has only quarry dives in her log book. So a good operator would be nice.
EBS,
I really can't recommend Caneel Bay. We found it disappointing on our honeymoon. Suppose to be highly rated and we rented one of the $500/night rooms, right on the beach... Figured honeymoon so price didn't matter. I would put room at Ramada level. Grounds were nice but nothing special. Since that visit have talked to others and they felt the same way. Caneel has lost its magic. Heard others talking about the Westin and they liked it, you would have to ask others on that but don't suggest Caneel. Isn't bad just not what it should be. St Lucia may have spoiled us as well. Also stay away from the resident dive shop, they are one of the worst I've been to. Low Key was great.
Spoke to my wife and both agree St. Lucia was by far must lusher, green, and more interesting island than St. John. Didn't dislike St. John, its nice, just we could have easily spent more time in St. Lucia (did a week at each). St. John does have a ferry ride to offer over to St. Thomas if you want to shop and fight the cruise ship crowds. Also diving the Rhone was cool and the stop afterwards in BVI was real nice (beautiful beaches).
The one thing that made St. Lucia magic from a honeymoon perspective is what I would say is the most romantic room in the Carribean (thus far). Costs $750/night (2 years ago) but if you can swing a couple of nights in it you will remember it for a lifetime. Book it far ahead. It is located at Anse Chastenet, they also have a 5 star dive shop at the base of the hill (where we did our open water). The room is high above the tree line built into the hill and has an unobstructed view of the Piton's. Make sure you awake just before sunrise. The room is open, no windows, no screens, just mosquito netting (no bugs, so don't worry), big room and wood paneled, open shower to the outside that only those with binoculars on the next hilltop could see you (above waist height).
http://www.ansechastanet.com/new/accommodation/accommodation.html
Premium Hillside is the room type, bottom of page, notice the woman in the shower and the Piton view... at 5:30AM you would think you were in Jurrasic park all appearing at the foot of your bed... birds singing everywhere... memories... probably 100ft+ drop from the room edge... If you go for it tell them you want the room in the picture, that was our room.............. Because of price we then transferred to one of the much less expensive ones, they were OK (and 1/4 the price). Hilton isn't too far away either which was nice. But the room is worth even $1k/night if it is available, especially first couple of nights of honeymoon. Again book it early if you can swing it.
From a diving perspective... At the time St. Lucia was great because it was our first dives ever... Your wife-to-be would probably enjoy it as they aren't hard and the shore dives from Anse Chastenet are nice (Marine park starts at their beach). Looking back now that we've done alot of diving, the dives were rather lame, but from what I have read on the board diving at the base of the Piton's is awesome just due to the view. In St. John we loved the wrecks, especially the Rhone... If you can take 2 weeks suggest you do 2 islands as we did. Airfare isn't bad on a multi-stop ticket. We've since been to Aruba, Curacao, Bonaire, Grand Cayman, and Dominican Republic... still St. Lucia was the prettier island, only negative is the poverty but you get that alot in the the Carribean (not in St. John).
Hopefully haven't confused you...
Kev