OP -- When you get advice from people who work with an agency other than PADI, please understand they may be working from a very different perspective. All agencies have differences in how they structure their courses and what the diving progression may be.
In the PADI Open Water Course (the basic course, the one you took), you are shown (and taught) how to do a "simple dive" that has the following parameters:
a. NO DEEPER than 60 feet;
b. A single tank;
c. No decompression obligation (that means you can always make a direct ascent to the surface); and
d. All dives are to be made in conditions similar to, or better than, the 4 open water dives you did with your instructor.
Some agencies have much more instruction in their Basic Open Water Class but they also include more pool time, more open water time and more lecture time (and most likely more money for the class -- not always perhaps, but time often does equal money). Are those classes better? Not necessarily but you will have learned more -- but perhaps not more than what you would learn if you took the Open Water AND the PADI Advanced Open Water class as a sequence. That is my advice, by the way, to take them as a sequence so that you get more instruction, more supervision and more experience.
As I went through the PADI system I was interested to find a comment (somewhere in the literature although I can't remember where now) that said something to the effect, "In the PADI system, once you have taken OW, AOW and RESCUE, you are now considered an independent diver." Having gone through those courses (and many more), I believe that is correct -- especially if you have a good instructor.
Some agencies think you need to have all that education before you can be turned loose to make simple dives, PADI believes it is OK to take them in sequence. Whichever way you go, you should end up with the same basic skill set and perhaps with about the same amount of money spent.
Side note -- I just did your 75' profile using the eRDPml and you end up with pressure group P and a "mandatory safety stop" -- I haven't checked to see what the PG would be if you used the RDP table.