Got back from STX a week ago. Do not go to Hotel on the Cay. The place is a dump and I can not believe that RCI is affiliated with this property. I would go for Carombola or Divi. Buccaneer is the nicest place on this island short of renting condo or house. We stayed at Tamirand Reef and it was nice. We left Hotel on the Cay and did not even check in. Trying to get week back from RCI now. I posted a report under Caribbean for more see it.