DaleC
Contributor
This is really about communities and their expectations of behavior. When we move from one community to another we sometimes find that the behavior in one doesn't fit the expectations in another.
These appear to be young men who are from a HS/college community of buddies who don't appear to object to any kind of behavior. As hunters they appear to have learned nothing more from that community other than to have the right tags. Now they have taken those values and entered the recreational diving community - Pow!
It is probably legal to BBQ and eat a dog at an American beach but most people know that it will get people riled up. If they don't I sure hope someone would clue them in (like Bob did). Patting that person on the back and reaffirming their strict legal right to do what they are doing isn't really going to help that person fit in at the beach. It will just cripple them socially with kindness.
It would be nice if those two young men could grow to become responsible hunters, and responsible divers. It's possible if they are able to connect the consequences to the action. But if they are to do so they need to learn what is expected from them by both communities.
Are cultural norms a legality? No. Are they a reality? Yes.
The people who keep justifying the "rights" may be correct in a legal sense but they are not helping those boys in any real sense. They are just continuing to keep them trapped in a cycle of perpetual pariahhood from the community they appear to want to enter.
These appear to be young men who are from a HS/college community of buddies who don't appear to object to any kind of behavior. As hunters they appear to have learned nothing more from that community other than to have the right tags. Now they have taken those values and entered the recreational diving community - Pow!
It is probably legal to BBQ and eat a dog at an American beach but most people know that it will get people riled up. If they don't I sure hope someone would clue them in (like Bob did). Patting that person on the back and reaffirming their strict legal right to do what they are doing isn't really going to help that person fit in at the beach. It will just cripple them socially with kindness.
It would be nice if those two young men could grow to become responsible hunters, and responsible divers. It's possible if they are able to connect the consequences to the action. But if they are to do so they need to learn what is expected from them by both communities.
Are cultural norms a legality? No. Are they a reality? Yes.
The people who keep justifying the "rights" may be correct in a legal sense but they are not helping those boys in any real sense. They are just continuing to keep them trapped in a cycle of perpetual pariahhood from the community they appear to want to enter.
Last edited: