Is money more important than the safety of divers in Bali??

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

divewench1

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Divemaster
Messages
339
Reaction score
129
Location
Kent,UK
# of dives
500 - 999
Operator, association fear closure will taint image | The Jakarta Post

As of Friday evening, the police had yet to reopen Crystal Bay, a favorite diving spot, to the public, creating concern among dive operators and the water sports association that a prolonged closure may taint the site’s image, as well as inflict financial loss on the operators.

The police have closed the bay for any diving following the deaths of two foreigners in diving accidents early this week.

On Tuesday, the lifeless body of a Danish businessman and former diving instructor Hendrik Kent Jensen, 43, floated to the surface more than one hour after he entered the water with two fellow scuba divers.

Previously on Monday evening, rescue divers spotted the lifeless body of a Japanese diver, Ai Tanaka, 34, at a depth of 43 meters. The woman had never resurfaced after entering the water at Sunday noon.

Officers from Nusa Penida Police had cordoned off Crystal Bay Beach with a police line and urged the local dive operators to temporarily stop taking divers into the bay until the official investigation was
completed.

“The closure may create an image that the beaches in Bali are in a terrible condition,” Surya Dive Center director I Wayan Sudana said, adding that the police should have coordinated with the diving operators first before announcing the closure of the area.

“Crystal Bay Beach is very popular among foreign visitors and its closure will disappoint foreign divers who fly from their home countries to Bali specifically to dive in that area.”

Association of Water Sports Operators (Gahawisri) chairman Yos WK Amerta pointed out that a prolonged closure would hurt the revenue of the local dive operators, especially since the period from August to September is traditionally known as Crystal Bay’s busiest time with a large number of divers flocking to the site to get a glimpse of the Mola Mola sunfish.

The local diving operators generally sell Nusa Penida diving packages, which include Crystal Bay and another popular diving site, for around US$150.

“From a legal perspective, I cannot give any comment on the police’s authority and decision to close the beach. They probably did that to enable them to collect evidence from the site.”

Nusa Penida police chief Comr. I Wayan Sarjana said that the ongoing police investigation was more than just an effort to determine the cause of the diving accidents. It would also try to determine whether Crystal Bay was a safe diving site.

“Two deaths are a very serious matter. That’s why we need to enforce a serious measure, such as the closure of the beach. We couldn’t afford to have a third fatal accident,” he said, adding that the police would bring in a team of experts to assess the natural condition of the site and to determine whether the site was safe for water sports.

Sarjana pointed out that the order to close the beach was issued by Bali Police chief Insp. Gen. Budi Gunawan.

“We will open the beach once we receive the order to open it from the Bali Police chief.”
 
I can see both sides of this. The first thing is, the authorities need to conduct their investigations thoroughly & quickly. Notice I said both thoroughly & quickly,... as the 2 typically do not mix well. Determine what went wrong in both cases. Was it a dagerous environmental condition that caused these deaths? Was it divers diving in conditions that were beyond the training & experience of these divers? Was it medical conditions? Diver error? Even though 1 was an instructor, it is possible that he may have been diving beyond his training/ skill level or may have made a fatal mistake (he is human, after all), or even suffered a medical problem on his dive. The deaths may be related or they may be completely seperate. Once the determining factors have been established, then it needs to be decided amongst the authorities & the entities involved if the area is to be reopened. Perhaps it may need to be opened to all, only more advanced divers or no divers at all. No, operators should not be risking their client's safety for money, but neither should the authorities be arbitrarily closing areas off.
 
I've seen a similar 'official' response to dive accidents in several Asian countries. In short, the authorities don't know what to do about it - so to save face and be seen to do 'something', they close the dive location for a while, twiddle their thumbs... then re-open it after a few days/weeks as if nothing happened.

Closing a dive site/area doesn't address a problem. With 3 scuba fatalities in a short-time frame, we can be forgiven for assuming their is a problem (although statistical anomalies/freak clusters can occur).

Those with insight into the diving industry, would look more closely at the cause of the problem, not the symptoms. The starting point for such analysis would be the quality of training provided, professionalism of dive guides/instructors..and ethical operating policies by the dive centers; adherence to safe diving practices, following agency recommendations, health and safety provision and effective risk management procedures.
 
The main issue here being Crystal Bay is officially closed but the closing is NOT enforced : you have even more boats than last week ... and you will have more boats in the bay in the coming weeks as the Mola Mola season has been quite slow to begin and is really begining now.

Untill CB is regulated ( = at least boats & divers numbers limited) + the regulation enforced, accidents will keep happening here.

I don't really understand the crazyness about CB accidents since last week as this happen every year here for the same reasons (6 fatalies last year, still during summer).

The good thing being we have more en more guests scary from the recent stories about CB ...
 
Its hard to say what we should do.
should u take only people with a min qualification? well one of last week was an instructor.
should u take only people with a min of dives? 100 dives well experienced but got the dives over 20 years...... hmmm
should u take care of ur divers, and take them to easier sites where the possibilty is less but there is a possibility to see the mola molas, maybe the best option.
money is not everything, we cant eat it.....
 
i wonder if its still closed off?anyone know?
diving can be dangerous anywhere,and one can drown in 2 inches of still water....
many operators throughout the world put money before safety....
this area can be dangerous,many down and fast currents.....
????
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/swift/

Back
Top Bottom