• Welcome to ScubaBoard


  1. Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

    Benefits of registering include

    • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
    • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
    • You can make this box go away

    Joining is quick and easy. Login or Register now by clicking on the button

O-rings for Divers

Discussion in 'Advanced Scuba' started by Akimbo, Oct 12, 2017.

  1. Akimbo

    Akimbo Just a diver Staff Member ScubaBoard Supporter

    10,997
    9,479
    1: O-rings for Divers


    Question:
    :openquoteblack:I'm a recreational diver. Why should I care about O-rings? :closedquoteblack:

    Answer:
    :openquoteblack:For starters, an O-ring failure could empty your Scuba tank in about a minute. :closedquoteblack:

    full.jpg
    (Table Reprinted by permission)
    This table appeared in Life Ending Seconds, 3000 to Zero in 72 Seconds, Advanced Diver Magazine by Curt Bowen


    :openquote:Don’t worry. Catastrophic O-ring failures are extremely rare, as long as you know what you're doing.:closedquote:

    However, O-ring leaks aren't unusual at all, and can prematurely abort your dive or detract from an expensive vacation. Fortunately, understanding them is easy and will dramatically reduce failures. Many O-rings can be safely replaced in the field with minimal skill and are part of most Save-a-Dive kits.

    full.jpg
    You can repair most leaks with some spare O-rings, a removal tool kit, a wrench or two, and some lubricant.

    What is an O-ring?
    O-rings are "resilient" toroids (doughnuts) made from a variety of materials and are primarily used for liquid and gas tight pressure seals.

    full.jpg
    Literally billions of O-rings are made every year. They come in an enormous variety of materials, sizes, colors, and shapes.

    Where are O-rings Used?
    Most divers are wearing about 50 O-Rings. Here are a few of the diving-related products that depend on them:
    • Cylinder valves
    • Regulators
    • SPGs (Submersible Pressure Gauges)
    • Dive Computers
    • BCDs
    • Underwater lights and camera housings
    • High Pressure Compressors, Nitrox mixing systems, etc
    • Machinery and fittings on boats
    • Commercial diving equipment -- like almost everything we use
    O-ring Types
    O-ring applications are divided into two broad categories; Static and Dynamic. There are so many creative applications that some can be seen as hybrids. Static simply means that the sealing surfaces are not moving under pressure while dynamic do. For example:

    Static
    • Scuba cylinder to valve seals
    • Scuba valve to first stage seals, DIN and Yoke
    • Hose connections on first stage Scuba regulators
    • The lens seal on metal-body SPGs
    • Port and door seals on underwater camera housings
    • Door and port seals on decompression chambers
    full.jpg
    The first O-ring that divers learn to use is usually the stage regulator connection to the cylinder valve. This image is of a DIN connector

    full.jpg
    The first O-ring that divers learn to service is often the hose to first stage regulator connections

    full.jpg
    O-ring grooves don't have to be round. This image of is an underwater camera housing. This is classified as a static pressure-seating face seal O-ring.

    full.jpg
    Pressure-seated O-rings like this one don't require robust clamping mechanisms because the pressure does the work. The four small spring-loaded latches are all it takes to compress the O-ring enough to make the initial seal.

    full.jpg
    This PLB (Personal Locator Beacon) housing has threaded caps at both ends with static piston seal O-rings. You can see the compression of the O-rings through the clear plastic tube.

    full.jpg
    Sectional view of a conical Acrylic pressure-seating viewport for a deep submersible rated for 1,000 M or 3,281' working depth. Similar ports are used for decompression chambers. The O-Ring only functions at very shallow depths, enough for the pressure to create a metal to plastic seal.

    Dynamic
    • Cylinder valve stems
    • Hose connections on second stage Scuba regulators and swivels
    • Hose to SPGs and dive computer connections
    • Button and rotary controls on underwater camera and light housings
    • Power inflator quick disconnects on BCs (sort of a hybrid but they are allowed to rotate)
    • Hydraulic and pneumatic pistons including counterbalance pistons on hatch-back cars
    full.jpg
    Hose connector to the second stage regulator is a dynamic seal. Look closely and you can see the brown O-ring in the groove under the lock nut.

    full.jpg
    The standard HP (High Pressure) hose connection that was originally designed for SPGs are also used for AI (Air Integrated) dive computer adapters and wireless transmitters for AI wrist-mounted computers. Note the different style "spools" with a separate O-ring for the hose and the mating device.

    Table of Contents for O-rings for Divers
    Post 1: O-rings for Divers (this post)
    [URL='https://www.scubaboard.com/community/threads/o-rings-for-divers.553724/']O-rings for Divers[/URL]
    Why should I care?
    What is an O-ring?
    Where are O-rings Used?
    O-ring Types​
    Post 2: How do O-rings Work?
    [URL='https://www.scubaboard.com/community/threads/o-rings-for-divers.553724/#post-8116451']How do O-rings Work?[/URL]
    Post 3: O-Ring Materials, Lubrication, and Maintenance
    [URL='https://www.scubaboard.com/community/threads/o-rings-for-divers.553724/#post-8116452']O-Ring Materials, Lubrication, and Maintenance[/URL]
    O-Ring Installation
    Material
    Lubrication
    Oxygen Cleaning and Compatibility
    Oxygen Cleaning in the Real World​
    Post 4: O-Rings Buying Guide
    [URL='https://www.scubaboard.com/community/threads/o-rings-for-divers.553724/#post-8116453']O-Rings Buying Guide[/URL]
    Measurements
    Material
    Durometer
    Making Custom O-rings
    Pro Tips​
    Post 5: O-ring History
    [URL='https://www.scubaboard.com/community/threads/o-rings-for-divers.553724/#post-8116454']O-ring History[/URL]
    Patents
    Enabling Technologies​
    Post 6: DIY O-rings for Divers
    [URL='https://www.scubaboard.com/community/threads/o-rings-for-divers.553724/#post-8116455']DIY O-rings for Divers[/URL]
    Underwater Housings
    High Pressure Gas Systems
    Custom Gas Manifolds
    Custom Scuba Cylinder Manifolds​


    Special thanks to the Scubaboard Moderators that helped me with this thread and XS Scuba for their technical assistance.



    Continued in the next post
     
    lukeb, markmud, Subcooled and 21 others like this.
  2. Akimbo

    Akimbo Just a diver Staff Member ScubaBoard Supporter

    10,997
    9,479
    Continued from previous post



    2: How do O-Rings Work?



    O-Rings are much different than gaskets. They are designed to move in their groove, or more properly "gland", and require very little force to achieve the initial seal.

    full.jpg
    full.jpg
    full.jpg
    O-Rings are designed to move and deform in the groove, which is why proper lubrication is advised. Unlike gaskets, very little initial compression force is required for a positive seal.

    full.jpg
    O-Rings will extrude and fail catastrophically when design pressure is exceeded beyond the safety margin, or the wrong O-Ring is used. That is why using the proper size, material, durometer, and lubricant is important.



    full.jpg
    The Parker O-Ring Handbook has been my faithful companion for almost 50 years. The latest edition has 292 pages and is a free download. The handbook's first paragraph is not an exaggeration:

    Since its initial release in 1957, the Parker O-Ring Handbook has become a fixture on the reference shelves of engineers worldwide. This book contains extensive information about the properties of basic sealing elastomers, as well as examples of typical o-ring applications, fundamentals of static and dynamic seal design and o-ring failure modes. It also provides an overview of international sizes and standards, and compatibility data for fluids, gases and solids.



    Continued in the next post
     
    markmud, Subcooled, rjack321 and 11 others like this.
  3. Akimbo

    Akimbo Just a diver Staff Member ScubaBoard Supporter

    10,997
    9,479
    Continued from previous post



    3: O-Ring Materials, Lubrication, and Maintenance



    full.jpg
    Most well-equipped "Save-a-Dive" kits include spare O-rings, lubricant, and removal tools.


    O-Ring Installation
    This is an expansive subject but here are a few guidelines:
    • Avoid reusing small inexpensive O-Rings. Carefully inspect for deformities and flaws if you do.
    • Take great care to only use compatible lubricants (more later)
    • Fastidiously clean all mating surfaces and the O-ring itself
    • Only use compatible degreasers and solvents
    • Avoid materials that shed fibers or lint. Foam makeup applicators are preferred over cotton tipped swabs. Clean metal, rubber, silicone, or high-pressure laminate work surfaces are preferred over fabrics.
    • Protect O-rings that pass over threads that can cause minute cuts and abrasions

    Protecting O-rings when sliding over threads has been an industry "best practice" for decades, but is rarely discussed in recreational Scuba diving.

    full.jpg
    Shrink tubing makes excellent thread protectors for installing O-rings on SAE J1926 straight thread boss connections used on first stage regulators. (Ideally use a heat gun to shrink the tubing or carefully clean soot off the tubing when heated with an open flame.

    full.jpg
    O-rings can be protected from thread damage on Scuba cylinder valves with adhesive-free Flagging Tape

    Useful tools include:
    • O-Ring removal tool kits and soft plastic O-ring picks (guitar picks or equal)
    • Air cans or air nozzle from a clean/breathing air source
    • Compatible degreasers
    • Lubricant applicators. Sprays should be avoided. Plastic syringes are excellent
    • Optical magnifiers and loops


    SAFETY WARNING

    Always verify that manufacturers rate their lubricants and products for HP (High Pressure) Oxygen Service before using. Specifications and standards may change. Standards for Oxygen Cleaning also vary wildly so proceed with caution.

    Material
    Nearly all O-rings were molded Neoprene when I was a kid but the variety is mind boggling now. The most common materials that divers will encounter include:
    • Buna-N or Nitrile, hydrocarbon based synthetic rubber
    • EPDM (Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer)
    • Viton fluorocarbon elastomer (FKM), 40%-100% Oxygen compatible. pronounced: vi (like vise) ton (like futon)
    • Polyurethane, often for O2 service
    • Silicone, popular on underwater camera housings
    Lubrication
    O-ring lubricants in diving applications should be used sparingly. Typically just a thin film is fine, just enough to make it shiny. You will see a lot of videos showing grease being heavily smeared on O-rings and glands for hydraulic and pneumatic applications. That is valid because great globs of grease in the system just adds to the lubricated media. This is not the case for breathing gas applications or in instruments like underwater camera housing and computers. It doesn’t matter how high the quality of the lubricant is, you don’t want it in your lungs or on the camera lens.

    The first consideration for choosing a lubricant must be compatibility with the medium and the O-ring material. You will see a lot of Silicone based "Food Grade" grease being used and it is fine for most applications but NOT for all. The most frequently recommended lubricants for Scuba gear O-rings are:

    For Air Service Only:
    Dow Corning Molykote 111 (previously Dow Corning Silicone 111)

    For Nitrox and Oxygen Service:
    Engineered Custom Lubricants: ChristoLube MCG 111 and ChristoLube MCG 129
    Aerospace Lubricants: Tribolube 71

    Quite a few other suitable brands and formulations are available.
    Caution:
    Camera housing manufacturers use a variety of O-ring materials and are very particular about the lubricants they recommend and warrant. Use lubricants that they do not specify or brand at your own risk.

    Oxygen Compatibility and Cleaning
    The catastrophic Apollo fire on 2 February 1967 prompted Oxygen safety research that dramatically expand our understanding. Unfortunately it was too late for two divers that perished in a chamber fire at the US Navy Experimental Diving Unit on 16 February 1965.


    Several government and private agencies publish standards for cleaning and material compatibility for high pressure Oxygen systems. Here are a few commonly used in North America:
    • ASTM G93, "Standard Practice for Cleaning Methods and Cleanliness Levels for Material and Equipment Used in Oxygen-Enriched Environments"
    • CGA G-4.1, "Cleaning Equipment for Oxygen Service"
    • MSS (Manufacturers Standardization Society), MSS SP-138-2009, "Quality Standard for Oxygen Cleaning of Valves & Fittings."
    Oxygen cleaning is typically performed on recreational Scuba equipment rated for 40-100% Oxygen service. Many military and commercial diving organizations will routinely O2 clean all of their systems for safety and to improve reliability.

    Oxygen Cleaning in the Real World
    Oxygen clean means a lot of different things depending on your context. A Scuba regulator and cylinder manufacturers might use a standard like those above while individual divers use a variety of DIY methods. Larger commercial diving companies will sub-contract O2 cleaning services or have their own portable and onboard clean rooms with:
    • Positive-pressure Class 100,000 certifications or better
    • Vapor degreasers
    • Ultra-sonic cleaners
    • Cleaning fluid purification and pumping systems for long tubing runs, cylinders, and hoses.
    • UV inspection lights
    full.jpg

    This article might help provide some perspective: Oxygen Clean - Is a Myth, by Bart Bjorkman (excerpt from Advanced Diver Magazine issue 10). Divers interested in performing their own oxygen cleaning are encouraged to investigate the Oxygen Hacker's Companion by Vance Harlow published by Airspeed Press.



    Continued in the next post
     
    markmud, Subcooled, rjack321 and 11 others like this.
  4. Akimbo

    Akimbo Just a diver Staff Member ScubaBoard Supporter

    10,997
    9,479
    Continued from previous post



    4: O-Rings Buying Guide


    The easiest way to purchase O-rings is in pre-packaged rebuild or soft-goods kits. That relieves you having to determine the correct size, material, and Durometer required. However, it is also the most expensive method by a significant margin. Divers that want to buy from industrial O-ring suppliers may find the following information useful.

    Measurements

    full.jpg
    Most O-Ring suppliers measure them by the ID (Inside Diameter) and the Width or Thickness (cross-sectional diameter).

    full.jpg
    The vast majority of O-ring cross sections are round, but not all. For example, the Quad or X-Rings.

    As a rule, round cross sections are assumed unless otherwise specified. The Width or Thickness can be measured with calipers or O-ring gauges.

    full.jpg
    Parker O-ring sizing cone and tape gauge

    Material
    You can specify the material you want or most suppliers can help you determine the proper replacement material from a sample. Don’t be fooled into thinking that color is a reliable indicator. It is not.

    Metal O-Rings are available for ultra-high pressures and/or purity, high temperatures, and for corrosive materials. They are seldom used in diving applications. Materials commonly used in diving applications are listed in Post #3.

    Durometer
    Durometer is the O-Ring material's hardness, or resistance to indentation. Albert Ferdinand Shore developed the Shore Hardness Scale and instrument in the 1920s. "Durometer" is used in the O-Ring industry for the value and the instrument that measures Shore hardness of resilient materials.

    Most industrial O-ring suppliers have instruments to check material Durometer and will test samples for you at the counter. Gauges are available for under $100 but are rarely required. Most O-rings used in diving applications are 70 to 90 Durometer but selecting the correct one can be critical.

    Making Custom O-rings
    It is rare that custom O-rings are needed in the recreational Scuba industry, but commercial and military divers frequently encounter them. Larger O-rings required for chamber hatches, viewports, and mating trunks are seldom available and quantities are too small to justify such large tooling for custom production runs.

    Extruded O-ring stock is available in large cross-sectional widths and a variety of materials. Formulations of Cyanoacrylate (like Superglue) adhesives are sold specifically for splicing O-ring stock.


    Pro Tips


    Bonding machinery is available for more critical O-ring splicing applications.

    Commercial divers and chamber technicians will often see full and half dovetail O-ring glands (grooves) in:
    • Chamber and utility lock doors and hatches
    • Bell and chamber mating flanges
    • Chamber to chamber bolt flanges
    • Hydraulic and pneumatic flanges and end bells

    Changing O-rings can be tricky. This video might help

    I'm embarrassed to admit how many times I started pressing an O-ring in a chamber door's half-dovetail groove from one point, worked my way around, and ended up with more O-ring than groove. Naturally all the old hands were watching the "new guy" demonstrate that I deserved that title.



    Continued in the next post
     
  5. Akimbo

    Akimbo Just a diver Staff Member ScubaBoard Supporter

    10,997
    9,479
    Continued from previous post


    5: O-Ring History


    Sweden issued a patent to J. O. Lundberg in 1896 and Niels Christensen filed a patent in the US in 1937. The O-ring patent was appropriated by the US government during World War II which dramatically accelerated its adoption, especially in the aircraft and hydraulics industries.

    Personal Sidebar
    I grew up around O-Rings so never gave them much thought. My dad had a water-well drilling and pump business and I played in his shop before I was old enough to push a broom. This was the mid-1950s and very much the "post war" period. I'm sitting on the shop floor playing one day while listening to dad talking to buddies about these new O-Rings, which I thought were just rubber bands that didn’t shoot very well. One guy was a flight mechanic on aircraft carriers in the Pacific and went on and on about how great they were. I had forgotten about this until writing this but it illustrates that O-Rings were largely unknown to the general public until after the vets came home.

    Maybe it's just my impatient nature, but I always wondered: What the heck took so long? After all, the O-Ring concept is pretty obvious when viewed through a modern prism.

    Enabling Technologies
    The answer is complicated, but largely boils down to advances in material and machine tool technologies. The wide-spread requirement for pressure-tight seals began with the Industrial Revolution in the mid-1700s, especially with the advent of the steam engine.

    Although O-Rings don’t require high tolerances or finishes by today's standards, they would have been difficult to achieve at production levels before the automotive revolution of the 1920-30s. Prior to that, sealing systems had to be much more forgiving. Early gaskets, seals, and packing were made from leather or various recipes including plant fibers, tree pitch, graphite, lard, and soft metals like lead and copper.

    Machine tool precision is an interesting chicken and egg problem. You need precision machine tools to make them. The key to this evolution is the skill and time of the craftsman combined with the best (most expensive) materials and processes. Those produce machinery that can more cost-effectively reproduce quality parts... and then the cycle repeats. Metallurgical sciences are also critical participants since they produce harder, more stable, stronger, and more temperature resistant metals.



    Continued in the next post
     
  6. Akimbo

    Akimbo Just a diver Staff Member ScubaBoard Supporter

    10,997
    9,479
    Continued from previous post


    6: DIY O-Rings for Divers


    This post is a collection of information for divers that want to custom build something using O-rings. A few examples include:
    • Housings to keep the contents dry underwater
    • High pressure manifolds for cascade and mixing systems
    • Special HP Scuba cylinder manifolds
    • Custom switch block for FFMs (Full Face Masks)
    • Decompression chambers, submersibles, DPV (Diver Propulsion Vehicle) housings, etc.
    • A housing to keep car keys dry during a dive
    Underwater Housings
    Building your own camera housings was the "big thing" when I started diving. These techniques are still used for specialized instrument housings in the scientific and commercial diving segments and are useful to inventive recreational divers.

    full.jpg
    Here are some underwater photography books from my youth. They were as much about making housings as photographic technique.

    full.jpg
    These are typical "back page" advertisements in Skin Diver Magazine in the mid-1960s.

    The DIY material of choice was Plexiglas because it could be worked with common woodworking tools, was affordable, and came in sheets, tubes, and rods. You could purchase O-ring control glands for 1/4" stainless steel shafts from companies like Dive Rite in the ad above and a few garage machinists in my area made them.

    The big problem was making the seal on the back where the camera went in. You could have a machinist cut an O-ring groove on a piece of Plexiglas tubing but cutting any shape groove other than round was a very expensive proposition. Some anonymous diver came up with this really simple trick.
    • Cut a piece of 1/4" thick Plexiglas sheet to a close inside slip-fit of the housing opening
    • Glue (chemically weld) it centered on the housing door/hatch/back, which was typically 1/2" thick
    • Stretch a 1/8" width (cross section) O-ring around the 1/4" thick backing
    • Clamp it down enough to make a seal, which was pretty easy to see through the clear Plexiglas
    • Clamping force was often accomplished with 1/4-20 UNC brass studs with wing nuts or stainless steel spring loaded latches. The Neilsen latches are still used today on a lot of commercial Aluminum camera housings.
    full.jpg
    Cross section of a DIY Plexiglas O-ring sealed housing with a gland for a control shaft.

    You can also cobble together a small housing using PVC plumbing fittings from your local hardware store.

    full.jpg
    Just ask for slip-socket PVC O-ring sealed unions.

    Warning: PVC Should NOT be used for internal pressure gas systems
    The reason PVC should not be used for pressurized gas is the failure mode, not the pressure rating. PVC will shatter on impact and little bits of plastic become projectiles like Shrapnel. An accidental bump can ruin your life, subject you to legal liability and the wrath of government bureaucrats, and give your local emergency room unnecessary practice.

    Fluids don't compress (for all practical purposes) so PVC is safe for liquid service because the pressure drops instantly when there is a failure.

    full.jpg
    Old underwater light housings can be a handy starting point for inventive divers.

    High Pressure Gas Systems
    You can make a lot of useful high pressure gas systems out of commercially available fitting, tubing, and pipe... which is probably a subject for future threads like this one. However, there are times when space constraints, ergonomics, and the added number of potential leaks makes it worth the trouble to use a manifold.

    Custom Gas Manifolds
    A common problem when installing everything from garage compressor systems through saturation diving systems is the need to join several inlets and outlets together. Connections may use rigid tubing and hoses and some of those connections may also require valves. Most custom manifolds are made from Brass or Aluminum because they are easy to machine and reasonably compatible around salt water environments; though Aluminum should be anodized in most cases.

    Flat or hexagonal bars are usually the most convenient starting points. Local machine shops drill the stock and install:
    • Female NPT ports using a standard tap
    • SAE straight thread O-ring sealed ports using SAE J1926 port cutting tools (SAE ports are best for Aluminum so the anodizing won’t be scarred).
    • ISO 6149-1 Metric Straight Thread O-ring cutting tools
    • Brazed (Brass) or welded (Stainless Steel) fitting tail-pieces
    Note: Hose connections on Scuba first stages are industry standard SAE J1926 O-ring sealed straight thread ports. The HP port is designated -4 or 1/4" and has a 7/16-20 UNF thread. The LP or IP ports have a 3/8-24 UNF thread are designated as -3 or 3/16".

    full.jpg
    Back and front images of a chamber gas control panel for a saturation diving system. Note the four manifolds that include check valve cartridges, valve cartridges, and internal connections. Dozens of fittings, tubes, and potential leaks are eliminated.

    Custom Scuba Cylinder Manifolds
    There are a lot of ways that specialized manifolds can be made using off-the-shelf cylinder valves and industrial tube fittings. Here is just one example:

    full.jpg
    Custom doubles manifold for bail-out bottles for surface supplied diving.

    full.jpg
    This manifold uses modified Stainless Steel DIN plugs and CPV flat-faced O-ring sealed fittings.



    End of Multipart Post
     
  7. CuzzA

    CuzzA Percoidea Wetwork for Hire ScubaBoard Supporter

    19,342
    33,745
    Akimbo and Compressor like this.
  8. BoltSnap

    BoltSnap Dive Charter

    # of Dives: I'm a Fish!
    Location: Nomad
    6,877
    2,898
    WOW!!! Fantastic work @Akimbo !!

    Is there a chance you can put all of this work into a PDF document (in color) please?
     
    Akimbo likes this.
  9. SoFlaDiver954

    SoFlaDiver954 Contributor

    # of Dives: 200 - 499
    Location: Ft lauderdale, FL
    183
    74
    Thanks @Akimbo excellent write-up.
     
    Akimbo likes this.
  10. Bob DBF

    Bob DBF Solo Diver

    # of Dives: I just don't log dives
    Location: NorCal
    11,264
    17,576
    Well that sent me back quite a ways. As a kid I remember learning how to make gaskets, and choose the material, from my dad as we repaired old farm equipment and old cars. Some of the farm equipment was converted to work with tractors, as horses were phased out when my dad was a kid. A lot of engine gaskets were only sold in sets which "are a waste of money if you only need one", I was told more than once.

    To this day I have sheets of gasket materials in a drawer, near the O-rings, just in case.


    Bob
     
    Fishyhead, couv, dead dog and 3 others like this.

Share This Page