One dead, one missing (since found), 300 foot dive - Lake Michigan

[broncobowsher]

Have edited accordingly. It was not my intent to imply that the CCR's caused the deaths. But they were deaths while diving on CCR's.

And that is different from just saying the deaths were on SCUBA? The implication is still there just in how you word it..

 

[cerich]

And that is different from just saying the deaths were on SCUBA? The implication is still there just in how you word it..

it's fair to look at if CCR. While I agree we would have many OC deaths if many folks were doing the same depth dives that are now common with CCR, CCR does have specific stuff that kills ya that is worth looking at

 

[Kay Dee]

your criteria, you decide what they meet, I wasn't aware it was a test.

It wasn't a 'test' by any means, it was just a straight forward question, poorly worded though it seems. And without knowing what dives you were / are referring to, l can't make any decision. Hence why I asked the question.

 

[Kay Dee]

And that is different from just saying the deaths were on SCUBA? The implication is still there just in how you word it..

In my opinion yes, specifically stating what equipment they were using is different from just saying "were on scuba".

And if by you saying "the implication is still there" you mean any (percieved) implication that the CCR's caused the accident, then it is you that is reading that into it / now making that implication, not me, as I plainly stated above that that was not my implied intent, and hence why I immediately reworded my initial post when called on it.

Look at it any way you like, but there is no getting around the fact that they were diving on CCR's, (which you seem to be trying to avoid?).

 

[cerich]

It wasn't a 'test' by any means, it was just a straight forward question, poorly worded though it seems. And without knowing what dives you were / are referring to, l can't make any decision. Hence why I asked the question.

i forgot the smiley ...

the two that were identified after my posts, EN and the Finnish divers

 

[Kay Dee]

i forgot the smiley ...

the two that were identified after my posts, EN and the Finnish divers

Thanks Cerich (and Nirvana).

 

[Marie13]

Someone got the Milwaukee ME’s report and posted it a scuba accident group on FB. Someone notes in the comments that Susan Winn’s RB has been found and brought up.

Log In or Sign Up to View

 

[wgw04024]

"content isn't available"

 

[Marie13]

"content isn't available"

Used to be an open group. Closed now. You can join the group if you want the info.

 

[SoFlaDiver954]

Used to be an open group. Closed now. You can join the group if you want the info.

Can you post the relevant info here? I dont have a facebook.