AndrewJD
Contributor
My buddy and I did a valve drill at the end of our dive today and during the drill, my buddy continually signaled me with his light while shutting down his valves.
Over the past year, I have observed this practice with nearly all divers who have taken a GUE course. Last week for example, I participated in a Trimix course. The first day we spent drilling in 20ft of water. The first drill of course was the valve drill. Both of the other students, who were GUE trained, did the same thing. While shutting down the valves they signaled with their light. The only problem is, their lights were stowed!
Now, this is not a put down of the skills of any of these divers, but rather a concern with regards to a broken training practice.
The purpose of this practice as explained by the students is to build muscle memory of signaling your team during a valve failure. I understand what GUE is trying to accomplish with this training practice, however, I think that in the end it achieves the wrong thing. Namely, it associates waving your hand with turing your valves.
The purpose of signaling to you team during a failure is to get their attention. Once you have their attention, there is no longer a need to signal. During a valve drill, when the team is already paying attention to each other, there is no need to signal them.
What are your thoughts on this practice?
Edit: The practice in question is that whenever you turn a valve, you signal with your light.
Jonathan
Over the past year, I have observed this practice with nearly all divers who have taken a GUE course. Last week for example, I participated in a Trimix course. The first day we spent drilling in 20ft of water. The first drill of course was the valve drill. Both of the other students, who were GUE trained, did the same thing. While shutting down the valves they signaled with their light. The only problem is, their lights were stowed!
Now, this is not a put down of the skills of any of these divers, but rather a concern with regards to a broken training practice.
The purpose of this practice as explained by the students is to build muscle memory of signaling your team during a valve failure. I understand what GUE is trying to accomplish with this training practice, however, I think that in the end it achieves the wrong thing. Namely, it associates waving your hand with turing your valves.
The purpose of signaling to you team during a failure is to get their attention. Once you have their attention, there is no longer a need to signal. During a valve drill, when the team is already paying attention to each other, there is no need to signal them.
What are your thoughts on this practice?
Edit: The practice in question is that whenever you turn a valve, you signal with your light.
Jonathan