Actually, at the risk of blaspheming, I think I enjoy surfing more than scuba diving. Requires a lot less work, not a lot of gear to haul around and maintain, no need to constantly search for dive buddies, no constant vigilance and training so I don't kill myself, no weekly back and forth to dive shops to get tanks filled, no constant outlay of cash for new gear, etc. With surfing there's something so exhilarating and inexplicable about slipping across a mound of water that didn't break yet, hearing the hollow lapping of the water resonate on the fiberglass board. Hard to explain if you haven't done it, but incredibly powerful. Well, for me, at least. I don't get that deep-in-the-gut thrill from diving.
But every week, at about this time, I automatically start thinking about planning a beach dive for the weekend. I'm not really sure why, though. I've always said that you really have to love diving to put up with the hassle and the risks.
I think part of it is the challenge, though I've never really felt the need to chase after big challenges just to prove I can do them. When taking my OW class I screwed up the mask clearing a couple of times and sucked a big slug of water thru my nose at the bottom of the pool, felt like I was surely gonna drown, and the instructor held me down while I coughed the water out. After that incident I told him I was done, and was moments away from walking out. But I decided to stick with it, and later realized what a service he had done for me. And now I'm determined to master diving. So I spend endless hours learning, dive whenever I can, and go thru all the hassle so that some day I'll feel like I've conquered it.
So far I haven't felt the real thrill, though. The kind of thrill I expect I'll feel when I can find conditions so clear that my mind can't rationalize that I'm floating in water, but instead it's convinced that I'm actually suspended in air and flying thru a canyon. I'm really looking forward to that moment.
Otherwise, I grew up on the beach and in the water, and I'm at home when I'm spending the day there, no matter what I'm doing. And I REALLY enjoy the people I meet when scuba diving. It sounds cliche, but I think that one of the best things about diving is the dive buddies you meet.
And there's something wonderful about driving to the beach early in the morning when it's quiet, and there's NO traffic (it's an LA thing...) and we have the beach to ourselves. That right there is priceless.
I really enjoy looking at sea life, discovering things I've never seen before, and exploring reefs. And the feeling of falling into the cool water after sweating profusely in a hot wetsuit while lugging 70 lbs of gear along the beach is delightful. And I'm really looking forward to getting into UW photography after I get my diving dialed in.
Maybe that's it. Maybe there's so much to look forward to in diving. Future trips that are so different from what you've experienced, skills to learn and master, people to meet, different types of diving to experience.
With all of that, for me, the answer to the question "why do you like diving?" is "Hell, I don't know".
Is my hour up yet, Doc?