Utila has great shore diving- easy access and a quick swim, and in most cases to both great channels and a fantastic wall right out your front door!
There is great diving all around the island, but for getting in lots of shore diving, you may want to consider the areas of Blue Bayou and South Shore.
South Shore is boat access - actually where we live and love it! Very quiet, long stretches of beach, unlimited spots to dive. Though most rentals/resorts don't nec. have transport to drive up and down the back road, but right in front of you is plenty to explore. AI resorts on South Shore to look at would be Deep Blue Resort and Utopia Resort. Some south shore beach rentals are Pelicans Nest, Casa Miradora, Utila Beach House and Pineapple House.
Blue Bayou is still driving access (scooter,golf cart, bike) from town. In Blue Bayou, checkout the oceanfront Round House, oceanfrontBlue Bayou Beach Houses, and Eagle Ray House (last 2 are more budget oriented, and Eagle Ray is just across street from ocean).
If you come to Utila, its a little different then Bonaire as far as you don't really drive around to a bunch of different shore sites, but the channels and wall just in front of where you would be staying are more than enough to keep you occupied for multiple daily dives for a week or two in my opinion...
Let me know if any questions-
andi
p.s- I'm not affiliated with any of the rentals or resorts, but have a website with lots of Utila info at
Utila Guide- your best source for information about Utila. | Utila Guide Honduras