I have had many a guided dive in SE Asia, and I have had many an unguided dive in SE Asia. I was recently in the Philippines, and all the dives were guided, and we were all happy about it. I would say the average diver in our group had maybe 800 logged dives, and some had over 2,000. We all could have done the dives alone, but the dives were better with a local showing us the way. I don't understand the reflexive aversion to a guided dive.
Yes, there are places where guides are required by law, including most famously Cozumel.
Two days ago the second dive of a two tank dive was a drift dive on a reef. We could go in as buddy teams on our own, or we could join the group with a DM. Each group had a dive flag. I would normally go on my own with a buddy and a flag. Unfortunately, I had a regulator problem, and it looked as if I would not be able to dive at all. My buddy joined the group with the DM. At the last minute my problem was solved, and I started to set up my buddy team. One of the crew, who knew me well, said, "Just go with the DM--you'll like it better anyway."
I did like it better! I just moseyed along, not worrying about dragging a dive flag, There was a nice current, so I could have done the whole dive with almost no kicking. That meant my only inconvenience was having to put on a little spurt every now and then to keep up with the rest of them. As the divers ran low on gas, they ascended up the dive flag and to the surface to be picked up. Eventually it was just the DM and I drifting along, and then we surfaced after a very pleasant dive.
Yes, there are places where guides are required by law, including most famously Cozumel.
Two days ago the second dive of a two tank dive was a drift dive on a reef. We could go in as buddy teams on our own, or we could join the group with a DM. Each group had a dive flag. I would normally go on my own with a buddy and a flag. Unfortunately, I had a regulator problem, and it looked as if I would not be able to dive at all. My buddy joined the group with the DM. At the last minute my problem was solved, and I started to set up my buddy team. One of the crew, who knew me well, said, "Just go with the DM--you'll like it better anyway."
I did like it better! I just moseyed along, not worrying about dragging a dive flag, There was a nice current, so I could have done the whole dive with almost no kicking. That meant my only inconvenience was having to put on a little spurt every now and then to keep up with the rest of them. As the divers ran low on gas, they ascended up the dive flag and to the surface to be picked up. Eventually it was just the DM and I drifting along, and then we surfaced after a very pleasant dive.