I record my dives on my OC1 and download them with Oceanic's software. If I need to record the dive for posterity (training, accident, etc), I take the time to vet that particular dive within the software for future reference. Using your PDC to record dives is easy, it gives you some great information and you don't need a buddy to sign it to make it "official".
However, rather than use this information for nostalgia, I do inspect the profile of each and everyone of my dives. Many things distract us on every dive including new gear, narcosis, fatigue, weather, and even the critters we came to see. These often cause us to overlook alarms, ascent speeds, safety stop depths and duration. A computer readout gives you raw unfiltered data to digest in the comfort of your office or home. It gives you a chance to lend a critical eye to almost every aspect of your dive and learn about your strengths and deficiencies. I was already a divemaster when I got my first PDC, a Suunto Cobra. I probably had 50+ dives on it before I bought the download cable and boy did I learn a lot about my diving style.
- I had learned to ride my NDL rather than to plan my dive and dive my plan.
- My Safety stops were more like safety pauses.
- My ascents were way too quick.
- My SAC rate was horrible.
- I had little or no air reserves at the end of my dives.
- My profiles looked like an old tree saw (no buoyancy control).
It was a great wake up call for me to see how I was diving on the edge, but not in a good way. It really helped me to focus on the three limits every dive needs: time, depth and air and has made me a far, far safer diver.
So, I would suggest that everyone log their dives electronically (with a PDC) and use that information for an honest, unbiased assessment of your diving. Your PDC is a wonderful tool and you should utilize it to the fullest.