Equalizing for Scuba and for Freediving is very different.
Most scuba divers are taught to equalize by using Valsalva. As as scuba instructor myself,I taught all my students to equalize this way. Scuba instructors teach this method for a couple of reasons.
#1. I can teach someone who can't equalize, to equalize in about one minute using this method.
#2. This method works fine for scuba. You can scuba dive to 500ft using this method.
Valsalva works by using the respiratory muscles in your stomach and chest to force the air up into your Eustachian tubes. This is the the ole pinch your nose and blow method. This method works fine for scuba for several reasons.
#1. Most scuba diver descend head up feet down, so the air naturally rises "up" to the ears where you need it.
#2. While scuba diving when you take a breath off your regulator your lungs will expand to full size weather you are 10ft underwater or 500ft underwater.
#3. Equalizing on scuba at 10ft is really no different that equalizing at 500ft. In both situation your lungs are completely full.
Many people that try freediving have problems equalizing and this is because they are using Valsalva.
Valsalva doesn't work well for freediving for several reasons.
#1. As a freediver we go down head down, feet up, so the air rises "up" towards our feet, but we need the air in our ears.
#2. As a freediver we descend much faster than a scuba diver.
#3. As a freediver when we go down our lung volume is constantly shrinking so its becomes harder to equalize because we have less and less air available to equalize.
Because of these factors Valsalva tends to fail at rather shallow depths.
Freedivers need to learn how to use the Frenzel technique.
To test which method you are using equalize your ears like you do normally, and put your hand on your chest. If you feel your stomach clenching when you equalize that means your using your respiratory muscles to push the air up. This means your doing Valsalva.
Frenzel uses the air in your mouth to equalize, as opposed to the air in your lungs. Your using your tongue and throat as a piston to push the air into your Eustachian tubes.
I personally do a
skype equalizing session with all my students before they take the course to make sure they are doing it correctly. During the courses I always do a hands on equalizing workshop where I make sure everyone has the technique down. It can be tricky to get someone to switch methods as you have to break the habit of how your doing it.