50ft dive after 1hr of instruction?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

k374

Contributor
Messages
539
Reaction score
6
Location
Greater Los Angeles
# of dives
50 - 99
I was talking to a friend the other day and he told me he tried scuba at a resort in Mexico, he was briefed for 1hr after which he dove 50ft and claimed that there was "not much to it". What can you really learn in 1hr? Isn't this dangerous? Is it common for resorts to do this?
 
Diving 50 feet? I mean most pools are 50 feet, the long ways, anyhow. As long as you don't go in the deep end, I mean, really.

As far as I know there aren't many laws or rules in Mexico. That's why it's such a fun place. It's like Las Vegas for college kids.
 
I've seen it done before. Not uncommon in a lot of places where resort courses are given.
 
Yes, lot's of resorts do this. In my opinion and from what I've observed, it's amazing that many more "resort divers" aren't seriously injured or killed.

And there aren't any laws regulating this in this country that I'm aware of either. 99% of what most divers regard as "laws" are simply industry standards. Self-imposed to try to make the sport safer. Scuba diving is, for the most part, a completely unregulated activity.

Need a cert card to rent gear? Industry, not law. Need a cert card to get tri-mix? Same. Dive boat won't let you dive without seeing your cert card? Once again.

Although D.O.T. requires 5-year inspections of cylinders, annual V.I.P.s are not legally mandated, nor are any certifications, recreational or professional. Granted, the threat of law suits will help curb much activity. But there's no law that says you can't print up a couple of fancy wall documents and call yourself "Supreme Instructor Trainer of My Very Own Agency." There's no government oversight agency that allows, or prevents, an agency from operating.

Why bring this up? Because in the end it is the individual's responsibility to ensure that what they do is safe. In many countries this goes as far as no real threat of law suits either.

P.S. - I prefer it stay unregulated.
 
There's nothing to it until something bad happens.

I've seen this mentality on a regular basis with motorcycle riders whose riding education is five or ten minutes in a parking lot and then lumbering, teetering, tottering out to the road, get on a straightaway and gunned the throttle to 100-MPH+ and claimed that there's "nothing to it".
 
If the new to diving guy says that there is nothing too it that usually means that he has survived!
I usually conduct such dives in areas where there is lots to see down to about 20 feet and keep them at that depth! I have not lost anyone yet I don't think!
 
Common practise in warm water resorts - I did it several times before I became certified. I've seen some stick to the 20'-40' range.

I remember looking at the other tourist I was diving with - I won't call him a dive "buddy" as there was probably nothing he could have done for me if something had gone wrong - when we broke 50' and thinking we were cheating death with this "deep" dive..... Now 50' is shallow. All a matter of perspective.

Further to this topic, once someone has dove with an Instructor in a Discover Scuba Course, the following dives with the same operator may be done with a Dive Master. I haven't got the PADI Instructor manual in front of me, but I am pretty sure this is the standard.
 
Seems way Irresponsible to me. With so little instruction what happens if ... Who can be a reliable "buddy" with such a limited instruction period? How can anyone be expected to handle anything that might happen with an hour instruction? So with this practice when the crap does hit the fan and someone doesn't live to tell the story it is a stain on our whole community; "another (*diver*) dies in tragic..." I can see the headlines! Damm I was having a good morning... I musta woke up on the wrong side of my AL80 :)
 
Intro to Scuba dives are supposed to be kept 40' or shallower. They involve a brief "class" and then a dive with either an instructor or a DM who has been signed off by an instructor to conduct this training. These dives are done all the time in tropical destinations, and most are done safely.
Charlie
 
I had trouble doing skills in 10' after my first two hour class !!!:rofl3::rofl3:
Guess I was lucky I didn't have to get in 50'.:no:
 
https://www.shearwater.com/products/peregrine/

Back
Top Bottom