Diving from your own boat vs. a charter

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I feel extremely fortunate to own a boat that runs well. We've had it for eight years and do most of the work on it ourselves. We recently hauled it out and had a mechanic go over everything for a 900 hour service on the motors, bottom paint, custom dive ladder and a new hydraulic steering pump. That cost a lot, but with insurance, slip fees, fuel costs and maintenance we average about $200 per trip. We don't save much money versus diving from a commercial boat but we can dive when we want and where we want. Our gear stays on the boat so the only hauling we do is to fill tanks at the shop a block from the marina and our cameras.

Owning a dive boat is much more expensive than a car but the rewards have been worth it. I have seen animals I would have never seen on a beach dive and am able to reach wrecks and reefs that commercial boats wouldn't go to for various reasons. Some of the reefs are too small to support more than a few divers at a time.

The initial cost of a boat varies depending on how comfortable you want to be while out on the water and how long you want it to last. We didn't want a yacht with wine racks and air conditioned salons but we also wanted to be out of the elements. A pilot house is perfect for diving, as is the catamaran hull. We don't get rocked around while gearing up in rough seas. Sitting in the sun and wind takes a lot out of you, as does shivering on a windy boat on cold days. Merry insisted on a marine head rather than a port-o-potty. We also have a small refrigerator, stove/heater, queen size V-berth and hot fresh water shower. Those few luxuries make a day of diving much more enjoyable. I added tank racks, dive ladder, stainless anchor which can be seen quite a distance underwater and over 400 feet of chain so I don't have to re-splice the rode every six months. It also holds the boat closer to the dive sites so we don't have to swim as we drop. Other expenses include GPS/Sonar/RADAR and two VHS radios, one handheld. We also carry flares, life jackets, O2 and a first aid kit.

My last boat cost about 20% of the price of our current boat but repair costs were much higher. Buying as nice a boat as we could afford saved us money in the long run.

View attachment 481396

View attachment 481397

View attachment 481410

View attachment 481398

View attachment 481399

View attachment 481400

View attachment 481401

View attachment 481404

View attachment 481406

View attachment 481407

View attachment 481409

View attachment 481411

View attachment 481408
I added chain markers every twenty-five feet so I know how much I have played out.
Now that is a dive boat. How fast is it? What’s on the back? Engine size?
 
[QUOTE\] It is my observation that you really want to be pretty good at both diving and boating when you start combining the two activities.[/QUOTE]
I agree. The OP needs to have a dive cox on board while diving (at least where I am) for insurance reasons. I would personally do it for peace of mind and safety. If you are new to boating, I would not dive and boat yet. Go boating first, then when you’re used to being on the water etc, etc then combine the two.

Get a fire extinguisher and all the other safety equipment needed. It’s not less expensive than a charter.
 
Now that is a dive boat. How fast is it? What’s on the back? Engine size?
We usually cruise around 20mph/32kph with twin Honda 150s but can get up to 40mph/64kph in an emergency.
We carry two fire extinguishers and all required safety equipment. The best advice I can give is to take a Coast Guard safe boating course.
 
We usually cruise around 20mph/32kph with twin Honda 150s but can get up to 40mph/64kph in an emergency.
We carry two fire extinguishers and all required safety equipment. The best advice I can give is to take a Coast Guard safe boating course.
64kph? Now that’s fast for a boat that size. Nice.
 
They say there is no such thing as a perfect boat. Mine is as close as I can afford. I'd love to have more deck space, compressor and a larger head but that would come with a lot more expense, including higher slip fees. My slip fee is $500 per month whether I take the boat out or not. I really hate it when the ocean is rough for days or weeks at a time. When it's good out there the boat is worth every penny.
When I was between boats I made a lot of beach dives and dived from friends' boats. It's still enjoyable but there is nothing like the freedom to dive wherever you want. Unfortunately, in boating as in life, freedom comes with a hefty price.
 
Owning a boat that lives in a rental spot at a marina and needs dry docked, etc etc, vs a boat that you park in your yard 400 yards from the boat ramp....
I do most work, like lower unit oil change, installing fishfinder, lubricating, etc.
I don’t spend much other than fuel and maybe $2000 on maintenance per year.
 
We debated about a trailer when we bought No Pressure. I love turnkey ability. We go to the marina about a mile and a half, set up our tanks and go. There is a haulout at the marina that we use when we change the lower gear oil. The rest of the maintenance I can do in the slip. We're in SoCal so no drydock needed.

Trailering the boat would require a trailer and truck, registration and insurance for each plus a storage space for the boat and trailer. I'd spend a lot more that way for the convenience of working on the boat at home. You also have the launch fees and dealing with idiots at the launch, especially in Summer.

 
Trailer or no trailer.
I think half of the internet could be used to consider this dilemma.

Is not for me my husband, we tried it for a bit and annoyed us to no end. But I'm not blind to the enormous benefits of trailering a boat.

Maybe in California is more expensive than a Marina but in Florida (most parts of FL anyways) isn't.
So with money not being a factor we could go on to the not so bright people you interact in the process of getting the boat in the water;
  • boat ramps? No need to get into this. Boat ramps are magnets for let's say "creative" people testing every "Don't" rule for launching vessels.
  • marinas? Unlike many may think, not all marinas are equal. Some appear great and you don't realize it until later on when you look at the boat with fresh eye and realize WTF!. Nothing major, just a bunch of little events that on their own don't mean much. Wasn't great for me, and not because I went to a discount place, because of distance to my house I went to the top rated marina in my area
    • On holidays they get additional personnel that is less than qualified to operate the giant fork lifts or even the boats.
    • Depending on who answered the phone when you call, your boat may or may not be in the water when you come in ready to go, the wait would be 20 minutes or 1.5 hours also depending who was the attendant.
    • the boats stored above yours may leak crud right on your vessel.
    • the evening you came late and decided to pay extra for them to wash it and 2 days later when you go onboard realize they didn't even flush the engine, much less rinse the hull or deck.
    • ...and more things that I rather not remember, it didn't feel like a "turnkey" situation.
So yeah ramps may be less than perfect but work very well for some people. My son trailers his boat and he loves it, I have a neighbor down my canal that has his boat on a lift like me, but keeps the trailer too. Every so often he likes to take the boat to the keys or to other states. To me trailering a boat is pure misery, and doesn't even have to do with the actual ramps, it messes with the way I like to drive.

As always it comes down to finding what works for you. I realized that neither trailer nor marinas were good for me, but I wanted a boat, so a lift was my only solution.
There are plenty of houses in Panama City right in the water with access to the pass so the OP can also pick a way for him to enjoy best his vessel.
 
I'm lucky to have never been a marina like that. At the marinas I've had boats in we just walk to our slip and go.
home_01.jpg


Of course, marinas are not exempt from the types you see at the launches.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ana
https://www.shearwater.com/products/perdix-ai/

Back
Top Bottom