Search results

  1. SapphireMind

    Two German divers drown at Gran Cenote Kalimba at Tulum

    What is your preferred gas planning in that situation? I've not found a great resource for gas planning differences for straight recreation open water diving.
  2. SapphireMind

    Two German divers drown at Gran Cenote Kalimba at Tulum

    Thanks to those that answered my questions! I'm not a cave diver and will never go into overhead environments, no matter how much training I have, that's just not something I am going to do. But I still like to understand so I can have a coherent discussion with others about the differences :)...
  3. SapphireMind

    Beqa Lagoon Fiji - Non diving activities?

    I've got a trip with my LDS that I've been planning for nearly a year. Unfortunately, I broke my dominant hand in two places, a week before leaving :( Obviously, I'm not going to be diving anymore, but I did convince my hand ortho to give me a splint instead of a cast so I can snorkel and...
  4. SapphireMind

    Two German divers drown at Gran Cenote Kalimba at Tulum

    My understanding on this, and I am a novice and not a cave diver, just always seeking to understand: the rule of thirds is not always conservative enough, and a rule of fourths might be better? I don't fully understand the path since I'm not a cave diver, that part was confusing. They turned to...
  5. SapphireMind

    Calm-headed response

    You misunderstand what I was saying. I was not saying that bolting was taught. I said "bolting to the surface is almost never the answer" and then said that the previous statement (bolting to the surface is almost never the answer) is taught in class.
  6. SapphireMind

    Calm-headed response

    Exactly. This is why I will never be a tech diver. I like the reassurance that the surface is always available. I was taught controlled surface ascent if you had air issues. Perhaps it's over-conservative, but if I have a major equipment issue underwater, my plan is to safely ascend in a...
  7. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Yes, because that's what the hubs do - they regulate the power more and keep it to a lower level, which lowers the chance of shorting and overheating. Realistically, there will be some cameras needing charged after a night dive, but the dive lights do not need to be charged during the night -...
  8. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Definitely not an issue. While the water is chilly, it's not freezing. Overheating is something that causes the fires with those batteries, so that would be a concern. That's why though it is important to think of safety changes, they have to be thought through, because the fixes can cause...
  9. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    I think it is more for when they are unattended/at night and people are not sitting in the salon.
  10. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    I forgot to quote the post that mentioned freezing as being problematic for sprinkler systems - not in CA it isn't. If the temp is below 32 f/0f, something is going horribly wrong and I honestly doubt people would be diving. I love this solution, simple, elegant, cheap, and easy to implement...
  11. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Technically, they would only need to interview one crew member to know the others were asleep: The one who initially responded to the sound/fire. If he had to go wake up other crew members in their berths, that would mean they were not roving or awake.
  12. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Boats this age didn't need to have interconnected fire alarms. In hindsight it might be a fault to be fixed. There is always going to be a criminal investigation when there are so many deaths. As someone else said, you can't turn back time to collect evidence if the assumption is that there...
  13. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Please don't misunderstand that I'm indicting the boat. I'm saying for everyone, passengers, operators and regulators, what we thought was sufficient has been shown to not be, and it doesn't matter how many times we were blissfully unaware of the dangers, now we know, now we should look at ways...
  14. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    The boat dives I've done does provide a modicum of assistance to the divers as well. Not huge amounts, but hands getting out of water/taking fins etc.
  15. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Coast guard rep on press conference said she spoke to the person who received the mayday call. She confirmed he was trying to ask questions, not that he was responding to information given to him.
  16. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Another thought, even if the batteries weren't the source of the fire, once they are superheated by fire, they could then provide a lot of fuel.
  17. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    As many people have said, this is a logical fallacy. Drunk drivers likely drive intoxicated a lot before killing someone. They think they are safer because they've never had an accident (proof they are safe) of course, we know that isn't true. Many synthetics do not burn easily. They melt...
  18. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    If anyone would like to read an example of an ntsb report, here's one: https://ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/AAR9108.pdf My cousin died on that flight, and when I started doing a lot of medevac flying, I got curious and read it. Incredibly thorough. If the ntsb is looking...
  19. SapphireMind

    Santa Cruz Dive Boat Fire Incident Condolences

    I hope it was painless and fast and their families are able to find peace. Such a tragedy.
  20. SapphireMind

    Fire on dive boat Conception in CA

    Do I understand correctly that the pathways from the hatch above the bunks also goes through the galley? Or did I misunderstand? Egress is always a concern for enclosed spaces like this. Airplanes actually evacuate fairly well - there have been enough examples to prove that. My biggest...
Back
Top Bottom