This is true, it is all a matter of personal preference. There are some who like the big boats and in the end it is all about what is important to you.ggunn:Some people prefer them. I don't, speaking for myself, but plenty of others have posted differing opinions; they like the slow pace, the opportunity to socialize, the onboard head, etc., that a larger boat provides. Not everyone who dives from a "cattle boat" does so because they don't know any better. DSFDF and YMMV.
In my case on our first trip to Coz we didn't know any better. We stayed at the Fiesta and dove with Dive House. We chose them because they were the onsite dive op and we didn't know any better. Did we have a good time, you bet, was Dive House a good dive op, yes they were, would we use Dive House again, probably not. Why did we go with Dive house on our first trip? Because we didn't know any better. Perhaps if I had know about the Cozumel Forum on ScubaBoard before we took that first trip maybe I would have picked a different dive op.
Now that we have have a few more trip to Coz and have learned more about the available ops on the island we choose the smaller boats with less divers per boat.
For us that choice is BXTS mainly due to the fact that during a trip in Dec right after Wilma when the Allegro closed and gave us no options, Christi went above and beyond to help us make that trip happen. Once we were there her crew did a fantastic job taking care of us and they have on each trip that we have used them. On a side note, due to the lack of tourists on the island during the Dec trip we had the boat to ourselves for a few days, and let me tell you that is a great way to dive
As I have said previously, it is all a matter of personal preference. Pick a dive op and have a great time