Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
I have this problem all the time. This "north Caribbean bio-province" can't be categorized geographically other than "west Atlantic". All those islands north of Cuba aren't part of the Caribbean Basin, and neither is the Gulf of Mexico. Yet they usually share most of the Caribbean biota. Only biologists use biogeographical province nomenclature, of which "Caribbean Province" at least has grudging acceptance for areas outside the actual basin. Most of the Gulf of Mexico, for instance, is categorized this way. But province names are only meant to be used in biological contexts.Rocha:Archman, the other day I had a discussion with a member in another forum about what the "Caribbean" really is, I was telling him that the Bahamas, Florida, Bermuda and the Gulf of Mexico are not part of the Caribbean. He didn't believe me, and refused to acknowledge that I was right, I guess I wasn't convincing enough.
LeslieH:I'll agree with Bispira but not with B. brunnea, at least not without a specimen in hand! There are a lot more clustering species in the "Greater Caribbean" (as one colleague puts it) than just brunnea.
archman:Somehow, I KNEW you were going to say this.
Once more, the worm people sally forth! Now I know what's going into the 3rd edition of Reef Creatures, more fan worms. Bleah!
****
"Greater Caribbean" hmmm... I like that...