Below is a list of Caribbean destinations that you can get to on Southwest. You may not always be able to fly direct from Dallas, you might have to connect from FLL. We are in the Chicago area and we would have to connect via Fort Lauderdale for many Bahamas and Caribbean destinations.
I have been to several of these destinations but not all. I understand that Aruba has a lot of topside activity but not the best diving, but some diving.
The T&Cs are expensive but have great diving (and lots of sharks and large animals) but the best reefs are rather far from shore on Provo. So you may be spending much of the day on a boat to dive 2 tanks, which might not be the best option because you are traveling with non-divers. I don't know of any shore dives around Provo, I think that the same may be true of Cabo. We've done liveaboards from both Provo and Cabo but that isn't an option when traveling with non-divers.
The Ports of Call hotel in Provo is nice and near the restaurants and shopping but it is not on Grace Bay Beach, but I think it would fall into a similar category as a Hamptons Inn.
Ambergris Cay is not the best diving to be found around Belize, but it is a major tourist destination. I haven't dived Palencia but that may be an option.
Nassau is expensive and the diving is good but not great but you will see a lot of sharks.
Rather than staying in Cancun it would be better to continue on to Cozumel for better diving. There are many lodging and dive options there, including all-inclusive resorts.
I agree with Damselfish that finding a condo, apartment, or suite on Grand Cayman might be the best Southwest Caribbean Destination that offers good diving, including shore diving, and lots of topside attractions and activities. Wherever you stay, make sure that you are not eating out 3 times a day as that gets very expensive, but that is true of many travel destinations.
Grand Cayman isn't just shopping and restaurants, there are many opportunities to visit cultural, historic, and natural sites, but you have to be willing to rent a car and drive on the left side of the road. Car rentals are usually a pretty good deal on GC.
Some places you might take a look at include: Coconut Bay Condos, Lighthouse Point, and Cobalt Coast (all north of 7MB) and Sunset House (near George Town and south of 7MB). Cobalt Coast offers an all-inclusive option but the shore diving can get winded out pretty easily, but they have a small, man-made beach. Sunset House includes free breakfast and Cathy Church's photo shop and gallery are on site.
I believe that Compass Point offers an all-inclusive option but no shore diving and it is quite far from the popular areas of George Town and Seven Mile Beach.
Since you mentioned Hamptons Inn, take a look at Comfort Suites. It is in the heart of the popular Seven Mile Beach and West Bay area. They offer studios, 1 bedroom and 2 bedroom suites and free breakfast. They are not directly on the beach but they are on the same side of the road, so you don't have to walk across the street, just take a short path to get to the beach.
Another place to consider in the 7MB area is Sunshine Suites, but you have to cross the street (West Bay Road) to get to the beach and there is a daily resort fee to use the facilities of the pricier Westin Hotel.
Our favorite is the Turtle Nest Inn and Condos in Bodden Town. It is in a quieter, residential area, about 10 to 12 miles to George Town and 7MB so you have to some driving, but it is centrally located so you can access most areas of the island fairly easily. A compact rental car comes with your reservation but you can pay for an upgrade for a larger car.
You can head east without encountering much traffic to dive with Ocean Friends or Red Sail or you can drive north of 7MB to dive the best shore dives like Turtle Reef at Macabuca, but you will have to time these excursions to avoid rush hour traffic.
You can also make arrangements to dive with many West Bay dive ops like DNS and Cayman University Divers and DiveTech and others, but you may have to meet the boat at West Bay Marina and factor in the rush hour traffic. Many of the dive ops will pick you up if you stay in the 7MB area.
TNI sits on a nice little beach but it is not the powdery white sands of the 7MB but there is good snorkeling right off-shore and 2 pools on site.
Good luck wherever you decide to go!
International Travel - Southwest Airlines
See where we fly.
- Aruba
- Belize
- Cabo San Lucas/Los Cabos
- Cancun
- Grand Cayman
- Havana
- Liberia, Costa Rica
- Mexico City
- Montego Bay
- Nassau, Bahamas
- Puerto Vallarta
- Punta Cana
- San Jose, Costa Rica
- Turks and Caicos