So far the tourists seem to like the touristy places to eat... Check out Buzzard's roost at 106, the Key Largo Fisheries back yard (paella thursdays & saturdays) at 98, Wednesday flip night at the Ocean View in Islamorada. The best cuban sandwich on the island comes from Publix and if you want a good steak or burger I'd suggest a destination with fields and cows (bring your own meat - anything not from here sucks from the store). I'll leave my actual favorites off so I can still get a table.