champ:
Has anyone swam with the Humpback Whales at the Silver Banks. I am interested in the opportunity to swim with the whales but I have only been able to find 7 day liveaboard trips. Are shorter trips available? or at least trips that mix snorkling with the whales with SCUBA diving on the reef?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You need patience and time to have good in-water encounters with the whales, so 7 day trips is the way to go , you spend 2 days goig in-out of the Silver Banks and 5 days there , less time than 5 days is not worthy . Each year an estimated of more than 3,000 whales congregate there so you will see plenty of whales evryway you look , the thing is that only very small fraction are curious about small boats and snorklers , so very few get close to you but when they do you will have one of the most amazing experiences in your life.
I have made some dives there and besides the tower formations of reefs are impresive ,most of the coral is dead or in bad shape , seems that overfishing and coral diseases are taking their toll .
While diving we encounter whales once and they looked as suprised and curious as us .
I think that operators going there don't offer scuba diving because is much better to use the time looking fo whales encounters and also because of security , that place is about 100 milles far from shore , definitly not the place to have some lost diver drifting away ( it had happened in the past ) .
If you want to make some nice wall diving ," hear" ( feel is more precise ) the whales singing u/w and maybe some sighting i can recommend you to go to Las Galeras on the tip of the Samana peninsula . You can stay at Hotel Club Bonito or Hotel Villa Serena , the diving is run by a couple of spaniards near by the hotels.
Also you will be close of some of very beautiful and quiet beaches .
Buena suerte