Which one: Grand Cayman, Curacao, or St Maarten?
- Thread starter rkru
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
Of the three, I have only been to Grand Cayman. It is expensive but has an overall higher standard of living than most islands. If you have non-divers in your party, it is a good place to go - restaurants, shopping, 7 mile beach, etc.
The diving there is easy. A few wrecks although not many. There are some nice deep sites that I like a lot. Many of the shallower sites are showing stress. One of my favorite dives is Tarpon Alley. I've seen 50 or so just hanging there. If you are slow and quiet, you can swim into the school and hang with them. Lovely. If you hang out at My Bar at Sunset House you just might run into Guy Harvey.
I've been to Bonaire but not Curacao. I understand that it is a shore diving destination as well.
The diving there is easy. A few wrecks although not many. There are some nice deep sites that I like a lot. Many of the shallower sites are showing stress. One of my favorite dives is Tarpon Alley. I've seen 50 or so just hanging there. If you are slow and quiet, you can swim into the school and hang with them. Lovely. If you hang out at My Bar at Sunset House you just might run into Guy Harvey.
I've been to Bonaire but not Curacao. I understand that it is a shore diving destination as well.
- Messages
- 26,281
- Reaction score
- 5,875
- # of dives
- I'm a Fish!
I've been to Grand Cayman and Curacao. Of the two, I'd rate Cayman higher on the tourist scale.
The diving on Cayman tends to be deeper, clearer and there's more big stuff per dive. Curacao is like Bonaire (same reef) in that there's a lot of shore diving and smaller stuff to be seen. In a week on Cayman we saw Turtles a couple of times, Tarpon, Rays and lots of fish. Some sharks in the distance out on the wall. On Curacao we saw turtles, octopii, barracuda, moray and other eels and lots of different fish. Even a seahorse. I also did the Dolphin Dive at the Sea Aquarium - $200 buys 1/2 hr. with a pair of dolphins on the reef.
Topside Cayman is pretty quiet except when the cruisers are in port downtown. (daily) Curacao you don't notice it as much since they tend to stay downtown. Either place is really crowded until the ships leave. Willemsted still stays open for the locals/tourists, Georgetown shuts down after the last boat leaves. Mostly because Willemsted is a much bigger city.
The West End of Curacao is pretty isolated and spread out between dive locations. Most of the good diving off Cayman is by boat, on Curacao you mostly go to the exceptional sites via boat.
Curacao is much bigger, more rundown and a lot more industrialized. It's a deep water port and there's a refinery just north of downtown. Probably several times the size of Cayman also with a lot more people. Some of it is kind of grimy also, hookers and such in one downtown area. Cayman wouldn't allow that. Curacao has about 15 casinos, Cayman doesn't have any.
Of the two, I'd say Cayman was much safer. Since it's the offshore banking capital of the Caribbean. On Curacao every resort had security and one of the places we stayed had industrial strength bars on all the doors/windows. We were warned not to leave anything valuable in the car at isolated dive sites. On Cayman we left extra gear sitting on the dock without incident. fwiw, we didn't have any problems on Curacao either but there are reports here of thefts that have occurred.
Cayman was more expensive in 04 than Curacao was last April. The dollar is something like 20% negative to the CI$ so everything costs more. Don't know if you've been to the Bahamas but Cayman was pricier than Nassau.
What are your property choices? On Cayman, one of the big timeshares is Morritt's on the East End, it's a 45min drive back to civilization from there.
Personally between the two I'd go to Cayman. It's much nicer topside and the diving is a wash in either place, both are really good just different. Except that a lot of Curacao tends to look the same after a few dives.
The diving on Cayman tends to be deeper, clearer and there's more big stuff per dive. Curacao is like Bonaire (same reef) in that there's a lot of shore diving and smaller stuff to be seen. In a week on Cayman we saw Turtles a couple of times, Tarpon, Rays and lots of fish. Some sharks in the distance out on the wall. On Curacao we saw turtles, octopii, barracuda, moray and other eels and lots of different fish. Even a seahorse. I also did the Dolphin Dive at the Sea Aquarium - $200 buys 1/2 hr. with a pair of dolphins on the reef.
Topside Cayman is pretty quiet except when the cruisers are in port downtown. (daily) Curacao you don't notice it as much since they tend to stay downtown. Either place is really crowded until the ships leave. Willemsted still stays open for the locals/tourists, Georgetown shuts down after the last boat leaves. Mostly because Willemsted is a much bigger city.
The West End of Curacao is pretty isolated and spread out between dive locations. Most of the good diving off Cayman is by boat, on Curacao you mostly go to the exceptional sites via boat.
Curacao is much bigger, more rundown and a lot more industrialized. It's a deep water port and there's a refinery just north of downtown. Probably several times the size of Cayman also with a lot more people. Some of it is kind of grimy also, hookers and such in one downtown area. Cayman wouldn't allow that. Curacao has about 15 casinos, Cayman doesn't have any.
Of the two, I'd say Cayman was much safer. Since it's the offshore banking capital of the Caribbean. On Curacao every resort had security and one of the places we stayed had industrial strength bars on all the doors/windows. We were warned not to leave anything valuable in the car at isolated dive sites. On Cayman we left extra gear sitting on the dock without incident. fwiw, we didn't have any problems on Curacao either but there are reports here of thefts that have occurred.
Cayman was more expensive in 04 than Curacao was last April. The dollar is something like 20% negative to the CI$ so everything costs more. Don't know if you've been to the Bahamas but Cayman was pricier than Nassau.
What are your property choices? On Cayman, one of the big timeshares is Morritt's on the East End, it's a 45min drive back to civilization from there.
Personally between the two I'd go to Cayman. It's much nicer topside and the diving is a wash in either place, both are really good just different. Except that a lot of Curacao tends to look the same after a few dives.
Damselfish
Contributor
Since you mention a choice between Curacao and Cayman I'm guessing Royal Resorts - Sea Aquarium Resort on Curacao or The Reef on Grand Cayman? If those are the choices I personally would go for Cayman if you can get it.
Curacao can be a perfectly nice place to go (no need to visit the refinery and hooker areas
) and has good diving, and the Sea Aquarium Resort looked nice enough. But it's in a fairly busy area with lots of stuff around, I'm not crazy about the dive op Ocean Encounters (you might check out the Dive Bus instead if you did go there,) and diving from there you would not usually be getting to the best diving on the island. Ocean Encounters will run a bus to their op on the west end once or twice a week but you can probably expect it to be a cattle boat. On the flip side it's good if you want casinos, to be close to stuff, and possibly have a more interesting/colorful/foreigh experience.
The Reef Resort is on the East End of Grand Cayman, so you would be a long drive from most of the shopping and restaurants, but close to the best diving on GC, with a good op (Ocean Encounters) right down the road. And the Reef is very nice.
Cayman may be more expensive. But you're not paying for the room, and I don't know where you're located, but good chance Cayman will be easier and cheaper to get to. And you'd be in a condo and will probably eat a lot of meals in (since I don't think theres anyplace open early enough out there to eat breakfast and make the morning boat, or that will serve you lunch quickly enough to make the afternoon boat.) Cayman is definitely a more "sanitized" experience.
Curacao can be a perfectly nice place to go (no need to visit the refinery and hooker areas
) and has good diving, and the Sea Aquarium Resort looked nice enough. But it's in a fairly busy area with lots of stuff around, I'm not crazy about the dive op Ocean Encounters (you might check out the Dive Bus instead if you did go there,) and diving from there you would not usually be getting to the best diving on the island. Ocean Encounters will run a bus to their op on the west end once or twice a week but you can probably expect it to be a cattle boat. On the flip side it's good if you want casinos, to be close to stuff, and possibly have a more interesting/colorful/foreigh experience.The Reef Resort is on the East End of Grand Cayman, so you would be a long drive from most of the shopping and restaurants, but close to the best diving on GC, with a good op (Ocean Encounters) right down the road. And the Reef is very nice.
Cayman may be more expensive. But you're not paying for the room, and I don't know where you're located, but good chance Cayman will be easier and cheaper to get to. And you'd be in a condo and will probably eat a lot of meals in (since I don't think theres anyplace open early enough out there to eat breakfast and make the morning boat, or that will serve you lunch quickly enough to make the afternoon boat.) Cayman is definitely a more "sanitized" experience.
DiverDonn
Contributor
If you're a diver:Grand Cayman. If your a Gourmand:St. Martin. If your a Historian:Curacao.
Good luck DD
Good luck DD
Similar threads
