cancun mark:
This is a crock too. Nobody is going to sue a pennyless Divemaster, what are you going to get except an expensive lawyers bill?
Except for I know DMs who work for free who are doctors and lawyers and live in million dollar houses and have bank accounts stuffed with money. LOL
As to the priginal question of the thread...divemasters usually work for free because they're willing to. Why pay some one who will work for free.
Students are charged money. They spend a fortune on plane tickets, equipment, resorts and dive boats. There's no good reason to train them for free. In general diving is a pass time for those who have money. Cahrge them enough so you can pay your help. How hard is that. If they don't like it let them go bowling and the dive sites will be nicer for me.
So many DMs are duped into working for the BS discounts they get on equipment. First of all you have to buy what the store carries which is often junk in the first place. But...most of the manufacturers give the store a key-person discount and lots of stors just pass that on to the DM meaning that their profit margine stays the same.
So...when a shop flatters you by inviting you to be a DM what they are really saying is that they think they can sell you a new equipment package while you're helping them teach their class for free.
When I had a shop I paid for insurance for my assistants and tried to cover their expenses and they got equipment at prices way better than key-man discount. I did other stuff for em too but I never made a profit so I never paid much in the way of cash.
When I was a DM all I got was the stupid equipment discount...which was the BS kind that I mentioned above. I didn't find that out though until I owned a store and knew how things worked and what they cost. My expenese weren't covered either.
Why did I do it? Easy. I was stupid enough to help the equipment manufacturers get rich without asking for reasonable pay myself.
I also worked without insurance because the store permitted it and (at least at the time) DMs didn't get the education in legal issues that DMs get. When I had a store I wouldn't let any one DM without insurance.