Why taking Rescue Diver was worth every penny...

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Location
Seattle, WA
# of dives
100 - 199
So, I'm a newbie diver and thought I would share a really great experience I had during our final confined water session for Rescue Diver. Thankfully my screw-up happened in a pool surrounded by great divemasters and a phenomenal instructor. It's kind of a minor incident compared to other confessions being posted here, but for me it was an incredibly important lesson. Primarily because for the first time I feel I really understand what it means to learn to be a better diver, and how that is actually different than just being an "experienced diver."

So the story starts with us taking turns with some scenarios involving surprises we find at the bottom of the deep end of the pool. In this particular case there were two divers in distress, one was injured but non-panicked, the other unconscious. My buddy and I moved towards them, having already decided to divide the problem based on who was closest to our respective sides. As it turns out I took on the "injured diver" being played very convincingly by one of our divemaster/instructors. As I approached him and began trying to communicate (OK? Calm down. Breathe.) he suddenly began to signal OOA at me and looked like panic was starting. After all the talk of how a panicked diver can be a dangerous item up close, I became acutely aware that I was now less than 8" away from a huge potential problem. The only thing going through my mind at that point was to give this guy my reg before he could reach out and forcibly yank it from my mouth. So, like a dumbass I just pulled my reg out (on a full exhale) and thrust it at him like it was some sort of shield to protect me.

First Rule Broken: Take care of yourself first, don't make two victims.

It was this moment that the seed was planted for a bad chain reaction. I quickly realized that the combination of having nearly empty lungs and a mildly increased heartbeat led to almost immediate feelings of air starvation. Again, without thinking, I reached to my left shoulder and grabbed the first thing to come to my hand and shoved it in my mouth. Instead of getting my integrated air reg, I had instead just inserted my snorkel into my now thoroughly air-hungry maw. I promptly used what little air I did have left in my lungs to perform a rather pitiful attempt at clearing what I thought was a second stage, and then heartily inhaled half of the pool.

Second Rule Broken: Stop, Think, Remain Calm

Needless to say I was shocked to feel the water rushing down my throat instead of the air I was expecting. To my credit I did quickly swap for the right mouthpiece, but with all the choking reflex that was trying to commence I just didn't have anything left in my throat that was strong enough to blow it clear. And by now my thinking was so severely disabled that any chance of realizing I did actually have a purge button on the end of the contraption was wishful thinking. I was going to the surface ASAP, Game Over, Do Not Pass Go - Do Not Collect $200. Thankfully this was all of 5 feet away at this point since from the first moment of inhaling water I had already started assuming an upright position. I wouldn't call my state of mind a "full blown panic", I was acutely aware of what I was doing and why, it was more like making a decision to get air without thinking of the other options available. The root of all evils to be sure.
Long story short, I broke the surface choking and gagging like a frat boy who spent too much time near the keg and found myself surrounded by the concerned eyes of dive professionals pearing at me from behind their masks.

Third Rule Broken: Practice Basic Skills / Know Your Equipment

Now, I try very hard to improve my diving skills and take to heart the notion of practicing something on almost every dive. I regulary flood and clear my mask, and I routinely swap my primary reg for my safe-second too. It's not that I don't practice, it's that my self-imposed drills weren't adequate to prepare me for reality. My reg swaps have always been "take a deep breath, blow bubbles, swap regs, exhale forcibly to clear, and taadaa." Never once have I actually used the purge button to clear it. This kind of practice, although great for instilling a false sense of confidence, does virtually nothing by way of preparing me for the inherent ugliness of a real OOA situation. Had I been practicing in other variants of the use of the equipment I would have instinctively used the purge on my reg in this case. And would have realized I had a snorkel in my mouth when I couldn't find the purge button.

In my mind this single lesson made the entire Rescue Diver course worth every penny and moment of time spent for me. Don't get me wrong, this is a fantastic course for all the other things we learn, but the scenarios and how they effectively replicate reality is really what made it worthwhile.

I have now made what I feel are the first changes to my equipment and my emergency drills based on actual understanding of how to mitigate risks. I've removed my integrated air second and installed a traditional octo on my first stage. I want to be able to have the option of giving a fellow diver a regulator besides the one I am currently using, and more importantly I don't want two mouthpieces hanging next to each other where I am going to need to pick the right one in a stressed situation. And from now on when I practice clearing my reg I will always use the purge button.

More than anything else, I am grateful that I got to learn this lesson in the relative safety of a pool instead of in open water in a real situation.
 
Thats why you wear your backup bungied around your neck - you always know where it is, wont grab anything else by mistake.

Personally I think that donating your primary reg while using an air2 type backup isnt the best idea for exactly the reasons you outlined in your post.

I have seen an air2 bungied under the diver's chin once - search SB for floater's Mach V post (I think thats the one).
 
Good story thanks for sharing. I'm planning to take rescue this summer, and it's the first course I'm actually nervous about...
 
Oh, what a wonderful experience to have had in such controlled conditions!

The fact is, virtually anything works when you're calm and have an infinite amount of time to sort stuff out. What matters is what works when you're scared, out of breath, choking (or, in one of my cases, lying flat on your face in too little water to float in but too much to breathe!)

This is why I like my backup reg bungied under my chin. It's where I think it is, all the time. I also ditched the snorkel, because I too frequently grabbed it instead of my inflator hose. The snorkel wasn't terribly useful, but the confusion it caused was at best annoying.

But the best lesson here was having the experience of "Oh, my God, I can't BREATHE" and living through it. The next time you have some sort of regulator problem, you'll be much more likely to stay calm and think through the issue. Or at least that was the outcome for me.
 
I had my first and only real OOA situation (I was the doner) on my first open water dive after finishing Rescue. Imagine that! Everything went fine, but I was sure glad I had just come off of Rescue and all of the practice that it entails.

IMO a diver is not fully, completely trained to an ideal level until they've completed a rescue diver course. I think every diver should strive to complete their training up through this point. Even if your only goal is to be an occasional warm water diver, IMO you are not fully trained until you've finished Rescue.
 
Agree with hoosier.

I tell all my students that the PADI courses should be renamed as follows:

Open Water----How to use SCUBA ecuipment without hurting yourself.
Advanced Open Water----Now that you can use the gear lets dive.
Rescue-----How to be a responsible buddy.

I go on to point out that in IMO Rescue is the minimum training level where I consider someone a "buddy" as opposed to someone I'm babysitting.
 
Thanks for sharing - sounds like a good lesson. Personally don't carry a snorkle - too many times it has been a source of problems rather than a solution. This just adds one more reason.

Also - you might want to consider practicing not having a reg in your mouth. You really don't need to breath for quite some time - even after you just exhaled. Lots of time to stop and think rather than just react. Hand the reg off, make sure they have it, locate yours, I try to purge before I put it in my mouth just so I know there is going to be air when I breathe, nothing worse than getting water when you expect air. (Easy to say sitting at a keyboard of course.)
 
I have to agree that you were so lucky to have this kind of experience in a controlled, safe environment. I had an OOA experience (hose came off of reg) during a dive 6 months after taking Rescue, and I credit that class with helping me stay calm and think things through rather than panic and bolt for the surface. Although my buddy was close by and I likely didn't have air for no more than 20 seconds, it felt like forever and I could feel the bits of panic around the edges.

The good that came out of my experience is that now I know I can keep from panicking and that I am capable of thinking in an emergency rather than over-reacting. We also regularly practice air sharing skills, mask flooding, etc. and sometimes spring OOA drills on eachother in the pool or when we're diving alone so as not to freak anyone else out.

Like others, I ditched my snorkel immediately after completing OW and the only next time I wore it was for Rescue training, when it was required by my instructor. However, it was stuck pretty far back on my mask strap (almost on the back of my head) so I wouldn't grab it by accident and it wouldn't be in my way.
 
It might also be a lesson in ditching the useless stuff. Snorkels are a lot of fun... when snorkling.
 
I happen to like the Airsource when I'm using my "integrated" BC (as opposed to my BP/W). I like the simplification of gear.

That said, your take away from this to get rid of the Airsource is, I think, the wrong take away. The problem wasn't that you donated a working reg (the one in your mouth) but that another (useless?) bit of gear screwed you up.

I first began diving in the mid-60's and dove a double hose regulator and used a snorkle (a pure j-type -- simple and efficient). I used the snorkle because when I was on the surface I had to keep my mouthpiece underwater or else it free flowed. Now that I primarily use a single hose reg, I swim out on my back and don't worry about free flowing. And since I can swim on my back I have absolutely no need for a snorkle -- hence it is gone. (BTW, when I'm in a PADI class (as a student/DM intern) I comply with PADI standards and have the snorkle -- but it is in two pieces in the pocket of my integrated BC! PADI standards require having one -- they don't require it be on your mask -- just on your person and available.)

I have completely "drunk the Kool-aid" regarding donating the primary rather than a backup reg -- and for all the reasons people have written. The primary reason, of course, is that you are donating a reg you KNOW is working.

So, for what it's worth, congratulations on learning a lesson.

Congratulations on taking Rescue.

I suggest ditching the Octo reg and go back to the Airsource/Air2 -- OR bungee the octo under your chin. In either case, you would donate your breathing reg (primary reg -- and, btw, get at least a 40" hose on it so you can have some space between you and the OOA diver!) and switch to your backup. And, of course, DITCH THE SNORKLE.

Snorkles are for snorkeling -- NOT for diving.
 

Back
Top Bottom