I'm not sure if you just phrased that poorly or you really meant exactly what you just said. Some militaries used to (still?) set their PO2 limits as high as 2.0 and IIRC some posters in this thread have alluded to regularly going above 1.6, even during 'working' portions of dives. So the literal answer to the literal question "do you (always) instantly tox if you go below 1.6 ppO2" is "no" and not "we dont know". Some people will tox fairly quickly, especially if the other factors mentioned previously are in play, but some will take longer.
If that's not exactly what you meant, maybe try restating it before the gasoline you dripped restarts the fire.